7.1 Mining and Indigenous lands

Mining on Indigenous lands in North America has a complex history, from pre-colonial small-scale extraction to large-scale operations post-European colonization. This shift dramatically impacted Indigenous communities, disrupting traditional ways of life and causing environmental damage.

Today, mining rights on Indigenous lands involve intricate legal and historical factors. Tribes assert sovereignty over resources, but conflicts with federal regulations and corporate interests persist. Understanding these issues is crucial for addressing environmental justice concerns in the North American West.

Historical context of mining

• Mining activities in North America predate European colonization, with Indigenous peoples engaging in small-scale mineral extraction for tools, jewelry, and trade
• European colonization dramatically altered the scale and impact of mining operations, leading to widespread environmental changes and disruptions to Indigenous ways of life
• Understanding the historical context of mining provides crucial insights into the ongoing challenges faced by Indigenous communities in the North American West

Pre-colonial Indigenous land use

Top images from around the web for Pre-colonial Indigenous land use

• 

  Indigenous Peoples & Local Community Tenure in the INDCs | Rights + Resources View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Timeline Prehistory and Antiquity - Environmental History Resources View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Native American trade - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indigenous Peoples & Local Community Tenure in the INDCs | Rights + Resources View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Timeline Prehistory and Antiquity - Environmental History Resources View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Pre-colonial Indigenous land use

• 

  Indigenous Peoples & Local Community Tenure in the INDCs | Rights + Resources View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Timeline Prehistory and Antiquity - Environmental History Resources View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Native American trade - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Indigenous Peoples & Local Community Tenure in the INDCs | Rights + Resources View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Timeline Prehistory and Antiquity - Environmental History Resources View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Indigenous peoples practiced sustainable resource management techniques developed over millennia
• Utilized diverse ecosystems for hunting, gathering, and small-scale agriculture
• Extracted minerals on a limited basis for practical and ceremonial purposes (copper, obsidian)
• Maintained complex trade networks for mineral resources across vast distances

Early colonial mineral exploration

• European explorers actively sought precious metals and other valuable minerals
• Spanish conquistadors searched for gold and silver in the American Southwest
• French fur traders encountered copper deposits in the Great Lakes region
• British colonists established iron works in the eastern colonies

Gold rush impacts on tribes

• California Gold Rush of 1849 led to massive influx of settlers and miners
• Disrupted traditional Indigenous territories and lifeways
• Resulted in violence, disease transmission, and forced relocation of tribes
• Similar gold rushes occurred in other regions (Klondike, Black Hills)
• Accelerated U.S. government policies of tribal land dispossession

Mining rights and land ownership

• Complex legal and historical factors shape mining rights on Indigenous lands in North America
• Conflicts between tribal sovereignty, federal regulations, and corporate interests persist
• Understanding these issues is crucial for addressing environmental justice concerns in the North American West

Treaty obligations and violations

• Many treaties between tribes and U.S. government included provisions for mineral rights
• Numerous instances of treaty violations related to mining activities
• Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 guaranteed Lakota ownership of Black Hills, later violated for gold mining
• Navajo Nation's 1868 treaty did not anticipate uranium mining, leading to later disputes

Federal Indian law on resources

• General Allotment Act of 1887 divided tribal lands, often separating surface and subsurface rights
• Indian Mineral Leasing Act of 1938 established procedures for mineral leases on tribal lands
• Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975 increased tribal control over resources
• Supreme Court decisions (Johnson v. M'Intosh, Cherokee Nation v. Georgia) shaped federal Indian law doctrine

Tribal sovereignty over minerals

• Tribes assert inherent rights to control and benefit from resources on their lands
• Tribal governments develop their own mining codes and environmental regulations
• Challenges in exercising sovereignty due to complex jurisdictional issues
• Some tribes have successfully negotiated more favorable mining agreements (Southern Ute Indian Tribe's natural gas development)

Environmental impacts of mining

• Mining operations have caused severe and long-lasting environmental damage to Indigenous lands
• These impacts threaten traditional lifeways, health, and cultural practices of Indigenous communities
• Understanding these effects is crucial for developing sustainable resource management strategies in the North American West

Water pollution and scarcity

• Acid mine drainage contaminates rivers and groundwater with heavy metals
• Cyanide and mercury used in gold extraction pose severe health risks
• Mining operations consume large quantities of water, competing with other uses
• Contamination of sacred water sources (Zortman-Landusky mine impact on Fort Belknap Reservation)

Soil contamination and erosion

• Heavy metals and toxic chemicals accumulate in soils around mining sites
• Open-pit mining removes vast amounts of topsoil and vegetation
• Increased erosion leads to sedimentation of waterways and loss of arable land
• Contaminated soils affect traditional food sources and medicinal plants

Loss of biodiversity

• Habitat destruction from mining activities threatens plant and animal species
• Fragmentation of ecosystems disrupts migration patterns and breeding grounds
• Pollution and changes in water quality impact aquatic ecosystems
• Loss of keystone species affects entire food webs and ecological balance

Cultural significance of land

• Indigenous peoples maintain deep spiritual and cultural connections to their ancestral lands
• Mining activities often conflict with these relationships, causing profound cultural disruptions
• Understanding these impacts is essential for addressing environmental justice issues in the North American West

Sacred sites vs mining interests

• Many Indigenous sacred sites contain valuable mineral deposits
• Mining operations have destroyed or desecrated numerous sacred places
• Legal battles to protect sacred sites (San Francisco Peaks, Mount Taylor)
• Challenges in communicating cultural significance to non-Indigenous decision-makers

Traditional practices disruption

• Mining activities restrict access to traditional hunting and gathering areas
• Contamination of plants and animals used for food and medicine
• Noise and air pollution interfere with ceremonial practices
• Destruction of culturally significant landscapes and features

Intergenerational trauma from displacement

• Forced relocation due to mining projects severs ties to ancestral lands
• Loss of traditional knowledge and practices tied to specific places
• Ongoing health impacts from environmental contamination affect multiple generations
• Cultural identity erosion linked to loss of connection to land

Indigenous resistance movements

• Indigenous communities have consistently resisted harmful mining practices on their lands
• These movements combine traditional knowledge with modern advocacy strategies
• Understanding Indigenous resistance provides insights into environmental activism in the North American West

Legal challenges to mining

• Tribes utilize U.S. legal system to assert rights and protect lands
• Lawsuits based on treaty rights, environmental regulations, and religious freedom
• Landmark cases (Lyng v. Northwest Indian Cemetery Protective Association, Havasupai Tribe v. United States Forest Service)
• Development of tribal environmental laws and regulations

Direct action and protests

• Blockades and occupations to prevent mining activities (Idle No More movement)
• Protest camps established at proposed mine sites (Oak Flat, Arizona)
• Collaboration with non-Indigenous environmental activists
• Use of media and social networks to raise awareness globally

Intertribal coalitions

• Formation of intertribal organizations to address mining issues (Indigenous Environmental Network)
• Sharing of resources, knowledge, and strategies across tribal nations
• Joint lobbying efforts at state, federal, and international levels
• Cultural revitalization movements linked to land protection efforts

Modern mining practices

• Technological advancements have changed the nature of mining operations
• Some improvements in environmental protection, but significant challenges remain
• Understanding modern practices is crucial for assessing their impact on Indigenous lands in the North American West

Open-pit vs underground mining

• Open-pit mining involves removal of surface layers to access ore deposits
• Creates large, visible scars on the landscape and generates significant waste rock
• Underground mining extracts ore through tunnels and shafts
• Generally has smaller surface footprint but poses risks of subsidence and groundwater contamination

Technological advancements

• Remote sensing and geospatial technologies improve mineral exploration accuracy
• Automated equipment increases efficiency and safety in mining operations
• Advances in ore processing reduce some environmental impacts
• Development of in-situ leaching techniques for certain minerals (uranium)

Reclamation and restoration efforts

• Legal requirements for mine closure and land reclamation
• Challenges in restoring ecosystems to pre-mining conditions
• Some successful examples of habitat restoration on former mine sites
• Ongoing debates over adequacy of current reclamation practices

Economic considerations

• Mining projects often promise economic benefits to Indigenous communities
• Complex trade-offs between potential revenues and environmental/cultural costs
• Understanding these dynamics is essential for evaluating resource development in the North American West

Tribal revenue from mining

• Royalties and lease payments provide income for some tribal governments
• Revenue sharing agreements vary widely between tribes and mining companies
• Challenges in negotiating fair compensation for resource extraction
• Examples of successful tribal enterprises based on mineral resources (NANA Regional Corporation's Red Dog Mine)

Job opportunities vs environmental costs

• Mining operations can provide employment in areas with limited economic options
• Often conflict with traditional subsistence economies and cultural practices
• Short-term economic gains weighed against long-term environmental impacts
• Debates over true economic benefits when factoring in health and clean-up costs

Alternative economic development strategies

• Eco-tourism and cultural tourism as alternatives to extractive industries
• Renewable energy development on tribal lands (solar, wind, geothermal)
• Sustainable agriculture and forest management initiatives
• Cultural and language revitalization programs linked to land-based economies

Policy and regulation

• Complex web of federal, state, and tribal laws govern mining on Indigenous lands
• Ongoing efforts to strengthen environmental protections and tribal rights
• Understanding policy frameworks is crucial for addressing mining impacts in the North American West

Environmental protection laws

• National Environmental Policy Act requires environmental impact assessments
• Clean Water Act and Clean Air Act regulate pollution from mining operations
• Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act addresses coal mining specifically
• Challenges in enforcement and monitoring on tribal lands

Tribal consultation requirements

• Executive Order 13175 mandates consultation with tribes on federal actions
• Section 106 of National Historic Preservation Act requires consideration of cultural resources
• Varying interpretations and implementation of consultation requirements
• Push for "free, prior, and informed consent" standard in decision-making

International indigenous rights standards

• United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) sets global standards
• International Labour Organization Convention 169 addresses indigenous rights to resources
• Growing recognition of indigenous rights in international environmental agreements
• Challenges in applying international standards to domestic policy and law

Case studies of mining conflicts

• Examining specific conflicts provides concrete examples of broader issues
• Illustrates diverse strategies employed by Indigenous communities and mining interests
• Essential for understanding the complexities of mining on Indigenous lands in the North American West

Black Hills gold mining

• Ongoing Lakota efforts to reclaim sacred Paha Sapa (Black Hills)
• Homestake Mine operated from 1876 to 2002, leaving significant environmental legacy
• Legal battles over land ownership and mineral rights continue
• Proposals for Indigenous-led conservation and cultural restoration

Uranium mining on Navajo land

• Extensive uranium mining from 1944 to 1986 left hundreds of abandoned mines
• Severe health impacts on Navajo communities from radiation exposure
• Ongoing clean-up efforts and disputes over responsibility
• Moratorium on new uranium mining within Navajo Nation

Alberta tar sands development

• Massive oil sands extraction projects in northern Alberta, Canada
• Significant impacts on First Nations and Métis communities in the region
• Water pollution and habitat destruction affecting traditional lifeways
• Indigenous-led legal challenges and direct action against pipeline projects

Future of Indigenous lands and mining

• Shifting global energy landscape presents both challenges and opportunities
• Growing recognition of Indigenous rights and environmental concerns
• Crucial to consider sustainable alternatives for the future of the North American West

Renewable energy alternatives

• Increasing focus on solar, wind, and geothermal energy development on tribal lands
• Potential for tribes to become leaders in clean energy production
• Challenges in balancing energy development with land protection
• Examples of successful tribal renewable energy projects (Moapa Southern Paiute Solar Project)

Sustainable resource management

• Integration of traditional ecological knowledge with modern conservation practices
• Development of tribal natural resource departments and environmental codes
• Collaborative management agreements with federal and state agencies
• Emphasis on holistic, long-term approaches to land and resource stewardship

Indigenous-led conservation efforts

• Tribal proposals for new protected areas and national monuments
• Creation of tribal parks and Indigenous Protected Areas
• Inter-tribal initiatives for landscape-scale conservation (Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition)
• Incorporation of cultural values and practices into conservation planning