7.4 Natural vs. Artificial Lighting Techniques

Lighting is a crucial aspect of production, shaping the mood and look of your shots. Natural light offers realism and efficiency, while artificial light provides control and consistency. Understanding the pros and cons of each helps you make informed choices.

Mastering the art of combining natural and artificial light sources opens up creative possibilities. By balancing color temperatures, adjusting ratios, and using modifiers, you can achieve stunning visuals that blend the best of both worlds.

Natural vs Artificial Lighting

Characteristics of Natural and Artificial Light

Top images from around the web for Characteristics of Natural and Artificial Light

• 

  Color and Color Vision | Physics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  PIXLS.US Blog - Portrait Lighting Cheat Sheets View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Kelvin Temperature Chart.jpg - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Color and Color Vision | Physics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  PIXLS.US Blog - Portrait Lighting Cheat Sheets View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Characteristics of Natural and Artificial Light

• 

  Color and Color Vision | Physics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  PIXLS.US Blog - Portrait Lighting Cheat Sheets View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Kelvin Temperature Chart.jpg - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Color and Color Vision | Physics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  PIXLS.US Blog - Portrait Lighting Cheat Sheets View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Natural light comes from the sun and is affected by time of day, weather, and location
  • Can be difficult to control but is free and provides a realistic look
• Artificial light comes from man-made sources (lamps) and is consistent and controllable
  • Requires electricity and equipment but allows for shooting any time in any location
• Color temperature varies between natural and artificial sources
  • Natural light is usually warmer at sunrise/sunset and cooler midday
  • Artificial sources have a fixed color temperature
• Quality of light differs between natural and artificial
  • Natural light creates soft shadows
  • Artificial light ranges from soft to hard depending on the source and modifiers used (diffusers, reflectors)

Mixing Natural and Artificial Light

• Combining color temperatures of light sources can create an intentional aesthetic
  • Mixing warm practicals with a cool key light produces a cinematic look
• Artificial light supplements weak natural light to achieve proper exposure
  • Maintains desired depth of field or motion blur without compromising image quality
• Bouncing sunlight or using it as a backlight combined with a soft artificial key creates a natural-looking image while providing control
• Lighting ratios between natural and artificial sources affect contrast and should be balanced for the desired look
• Diffusion materials (scrims, silks) blend natural and artificial light to create a seamless look

Adapting to Changing Light

Adjusting for Shifting Sunlight

• Sun's angle and intensity change throughout the day, affecting exposure and color temperature
  • Requires constant monitoring and adjustment to maintain consistency
• Techniques to adapt include changing camera settings (aperture, shutter speed, ISO), using lens filters, adding light modifiers (diffusion), or supplementing with artificial light
• White balance should be adjusted as color temperature shifts to maintain accurate colors
  • Using a grey card or other reference can ensure consistency across shots
• Time of day should be strategically chosen based on the desired look
  • Golden hour provides warm, soft light while midday is harsh and contrasty
• Weather conditions (clouds, rain, haze) affect available light and may require additional contingencies or equipment

Location and Environment Considerations

• Shooting on location versus in a studio affects the choice of natural or artificial lighting
  • Based on environment, logistics, and desired look
• Exterior shoots often rely on natural light for realism and efficiency
  • Requires ample time to work with changing conditions
• Interior or low-light shoots necessitate artificial lighting for exposure and control
• Mixing natural and artificial light when shooting on location can leverage the benefits of each
  • Requires skill to match exposure and color convincingly

Combining Lighting Sources

Balancing Mixed Lighting

• Lighting ratios between natural and artificial sources affect contrast and should be balanced for the desired look
  • High contrast ratios create dramatic images while lower ratios appear more natural
• Color temperature differences can be corrected with gels or white balance settings
  • Matching the color of artificial lights to the existing natural light maintains realism
• Diffusion materials (scrims, silks) blend natural and artificial light to create a seamless look
  • Softens shadows and reduces contrast between sources
• Bouncing artificial light off surfaces (walls, ceilings) can help it mix more naturally with available light
• Adding artificial fill light to shadows created by natural light provides control while maintaining a realistic look

Creative Applications of Mixed Lighting

• Combining color temperatures of light sources can create an intentional aesthetic
  • Mixing warm practicals (lamps, candles) with a cool key light produces a cinematic look
  • Using colored gels on artificial sources introduces visual interest and mood
• Hard artificial light combined with soft natural light generates pleasing contrast
  • Directional artificial backlight or rim light with diffused natural key
• Bouncing sunlight with reflectors enhances natural light while providing some control
  • Supplements weak natural light or adds sparkle to highlights
• Simulating natural light with large diffused artificial sources creates a consistent, controllable look
  • Useful for interior scenes that need to match an exterior look

Benefits and Drawbacks of Lighting Choices

Advantages and Limitations of Natural Light

• Natural light is often preferred for realism, cost savings, and efficiency
  • Provides an authentic look and feel to images
  • Eliminates the need for expensive lighting equipment and setup time
• Lacks control and consistency compared to artificial sources
  • Subject to changing conditions and weather
  • Difficult to modify quality or direction of light
• Best suited for exterior shoots with ample time and flexibility
  • Documentaries, reality TV, guerrilla-style productions benefit from natural light
• Challenging to match exposure and color temperature when combining with artificial sources
  • Requires careful planning and skilled execution

Pros and Cons of Artificial Light

• Artificial light provides complete control over exposure, color, and quality
  • Allows for consistency across shots and scenes
  • Can be shaped and modified with a variety of tools (barn doors, snoots, gobos)
• Requires more equipment, power, and setup time compared to natural light
  • Higher production costs and logistics for larger lighting packages
  • Longer setup and breakdown times can impact shooting schedule
• Necessary for low-light or night shoots where natural light is unavailable
  • Interiors, studios, or locations with limited windows need artificial sources
• Mixing artificial light with natural light offers creative control with a realistic look
  • Leveraging the benefits of each type yields the most flexibility
  • Requires skill to match exposure and color convincingly