7.5 Neurological disorders and musical ability

Music and the brain are intricately connected. Neurological disorders can profoundly impact musical abilities, affecting perception, production, and emotional processing. These disorders provide valuable insights into the neural basis of music and its potential therapeutic applications.

Studying how brain damage affects musical skills reveals the complex network of brain regions involved in music. From the auditory cortex for pitch perception to the motor cortex for instrument playing, different areas contribute to our musical experiences and abilities.

Neurological disorders affecting musical ability

• Neurological disorders can impact various aspects of musical ability, including perception, production, and emotional processing of music
• Studying how brain damage and neurological conditions affect musical skills provides insights into the neural basis of music and its therapeutic potential
• Different types of musical deficits arise depending on the specific brain regions and networks that are disrupted

Auditory cortex for pitch perception

Top images from around the web for Auditory cortex for pitch perception

• 

  Frontiers | The neural processing of hierarchical structure in music and speech at different ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Extensive Tonotopic Mapping across Auditory Cortex Is Recapitulated by Spectrally Directed ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Auditory Pathways to the Brain – Introduction to Sensation and Perception View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | The neural processing of hierarchical structure in music and speech at different ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Extensive Tonotopic Mapping across Auditory Cortex Is Recapitulated by Spectrally Directed ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Auditory cortex for pitch perception

• 

  Frontiers | The neural processing of hierarchical structure in music and speech at different ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Extensive Tonotopic Mapping across Auditory Cortex Is Recapitulated by Spectrally Directed ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Auditory Pathways to the Brain – Introduction to Sensation and Perception View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | The neural processing of hierarchical structure in music and speech at different ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Extensive Tonotopic Mapping across Auditory Cortex Is Recapitulated by Spectrally Directed ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• The auditory cortex, located in the temporal lobes, is crucial for processing and perceiving pitch, which is a fundamental element of music
• Damage to the auditory cortex can lead to deficits in pitch discrimination, pitch matching, and melody recognition
• Neuroimaging studies have shown that the auditory cortex is activated when listening to musical pitches and harmonies
  • For example, fMRI scans demonstrate increased blood flow in the auditory cortex when participants listen to musical tones compared to noise

Motor cortex for playing instruments

• The motor cortex, situated in the frontal lobes, controls voluntary movements and is essential for playing musical instruments
• Skilled musicians show enhanced activation and plasticity in the motor cortex, reflecting their fine-tuned motor control and coordination
• Damage to the motor cortex can impair the ability to execute complex musical movements, such as fingering patterns on a piano or strumming a guitar
  • Case studies have described musicians with focal motor cortex lesions who struggle with dexterity and precision in their instrumental playing

Cerebellum for rhythm and timing

• The cerebellum, located at the back of the brain, plays a critical role in timing, rhythm, and synchronization in music
• Patients with cerebellar damage often exhibit impairments in perceiving and producing rhythmic patterns, as well as difficulty with temporal aspects of music
• Neuroimaging research has revealed cerebellar activation during tasks involving musical rhythm and beat perception
  • For instance, PET scans show increased cerebellar activity when participants listen to rhythmic sequences compared to irregular beats

Types of musical deficits from brain damage

Amusia from temporal lobe lesions

• Amusia, also known as "tone deafness," is a disorder characterized by the inability to perceive or produce pitch and melody in music
• Lesions in the temporal lobes, particularly in the superior temporal gyrus and planum temporale, are associated with acquired amusia
• Individuals with amusia struggle with tasks such as detecting out-of-tune notes, singing in tune, and recognizing familiar melodies
  • One famous case is that of composer Maurice Ravel, who developed amusia following a brain injury and could no longer appreciate or create music

Dysrhythmia from cerebellar dysfunction

• Dysrhythmia refers to the impairment of rhythm perception and production resulting from cerebellar dysfunction
• Patients with cerebellar damage may have difficulty synchronizing movements to a beat, maintaining a steady tempo, or discriminating between rhythmic patterns
• Studies have shown that individuals with cerebellar ataxia perform poorly on tasks involving rhythm reproduction and beat synchronization
  • For example, patients with spinocerebellar ataxia demonstrate increased variability and errors in tapping to a metronome beat compared to healthy controls

Dystonia interfering with motor control

• Dystonia is a movement disorder characterized by involuntary muscle contractions and abnormal postures, which can affect musical performance
• Musicians with focal hand dystonia, also known as musician's dystonia, experience a loss of fine motor control and coordination in specific fingers or hands
• Dystonia can be task-specific, meaning it only occurs during certain musical activities, such as playing a particular instrument or performing a specific technique
  • Renowned pianists, such as Leon Fleisher and Gary Graffman, have struggled with focal hand dystonia that impacted their ability to perform at a high level

Neurodegenerative diseases impacting music

Alzheimer's disease and musical memory

• Alzheimer's disease (AD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder that primarily affects memory and cognitive functions
• Interestingly, musical memory and the ability to enjoy music often remain relatively preserved in individuals with AD, even in advanced stages of the disease
• Familiar songs and melodies can evoke strong emotional responses and autobiographical memories in AD patients, suggesting a dissociation between musical and other forms of memory
  • Studies have shown that AD patients can still recognize and sing along to well-known songs from their past, despite severe deficits in other memory domains

Parkinson's disease and rhythmic abilities

• Parkinson's disease (PD) is a neurodegenerative disorder characterized by motor symptoms such as tremor, rigidity, and bradykinesia
• PD patients often experience difficulties with rhythmic aspects of music, including beat perception, synchronization, and motor timing
• However, rhythmic auditory stimulation (RAS) and music therapy have shown promise in improving gait, mobility, and motor function in PD patients
  • Research has demonstrated that walking to rhythmic cues, such as metronome beats or marching music, can help PD patients regulate their stride length and cadence

Huntington's disease effects on music cognition

• Huntington's disease (HD) is an inherited neurodegenerative disorder that affects movement, cognition, and behavior
• HD patients may exhibit deficits in music perception, including pitch discrimination, melody recognition, and emotional processing of music
• Studies have reported that HD patients have difficulty identifying emotions conveyed through music and show reduced physiological responses to emotionally charged musical excerpts
  • For instance, HD patients demonstrate blunted skin conductance responses and reduced heart rate variability when listening to happy or sad music compared to healthy controls

Stroke and acquired musical deficits

Right hemisphere strokes vs left hemisphere

• Strokes involving the right or left hemispheres of the brain can result in different types of musical deficits
• Right hemisphere strokes are more commonly associated with impairments in pitch perception, melody recognition, and emotional processing of music
• Left hemisphere strokes, particularly in the frontal and temporal lobes, are more likely to affect rhythm perception, musical syntax, and verbal aspects of music
  • Case studies have described patients with right hemisphere damage who have difficulty recognizing familiar tunes or distinguishing between different musical emotions

Recovery of musical function after stroke

• The recovery of musical abilities after a stroke depends on various factors, including the location and extent of the brain damage, as well as individual differences in brain plasticity and rehabilitation
• Some patients may experience spontaneous recovery of musical functions in the weeks or months following a stroke, while others may require targeted interventions and therapy
• Music therapy and musical training have shown potential in promoting the recovery of motor, language, and cognitive functions after stroke
  • For example, melodic intonation therapy, which involves singing phrases with exaggerated pitch and rhythm, has been used to help stroke patients with aphasia regain verbal communication skills

Music therapy for stroke rehabilitation

• Music therapy is a therapeutic approach that uses music interventions to address physical, emotional, cognitive, and social needs of individuals
• In stroke rehabilitation, music therapy can be used to target specific deficits, such as motor impairments, speech difficulties, and mood disorders
• Techniques used in music therapy for stroke patients include rhythmic auditory stimulation, singing, instrument playing, and music listening
  • Studies have shown that rhythmic auditory stimulation, which involves synchronizing movements to a rhythmic beat, can improve gait parameters and upper limb function in stroke patients

Epilepsy and musicogenic seizures

Temporal lobe epilepsy triggering seizures

• Temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) is a type of epilepsy characterized by recurrent seizures originating in the temporal lobes of the brain
• In some cases, specific musical stimuli can trigger seizures in individuals with TLE, a phenomenon known as musicogenic epilepsy
• Musicogenic seizures are often associated with strong emotional responses to music and may be provoked by certain genres, composers, or even specific songs
  • One famous example is the case of a patient who experienced seizures when listening to the song "Bolero" by Maurice Ravel

Musical hallucinations in epileptic auras

• Epileptic auras are subjective sensations or experiences that can occur before the onset of a seizure
• Some patients with TLE report musical hallucinations during their auras, which can include hearing familiar or novel melodies, instrumental music, or even complete songs
• These musical hallucinations are thought to arise from abnormal electrical activity in the temporal lobes, particularly in regions involved in auditory processing and memory
  • Case reports have described patients who experience vivid and complex musical hallucinations, such as hearing a full orchestra or a choir singing during their epileptic auras

Anticonvulsant drugs affecting music perception

• Anticonvulsant drugs, used to control and prevent seizures in epilepsy, can sometimes have side effects that impact musical perception and appreciation
• Some patients on anticonvulsant medications report changes in their ability to enjoy or emotionally connect with music, a phenomenon known as music anhedonia
• Certain anticonvulsants, such as topiramate and carbamazepine, have been associated with reduced pleasure and emotional responsiveness to music
  • Studies have shown that patients taking these medications may rate music as less pleasant or emotionally evocative compared to healthy controls or patients on other anticonvulsants

Savant syndrome and exceptional musical talents

Absolute pitch in musical savants

• Absolute pitch, also known as perfect pitch, is the rare ability to identify or produce a specific musical note without any reference tone
• Musical savants, individuals with exceptional musical abilities despite cognitive or developmental disabilities, often possess absolute pitch
• The prevalence of absolute pitch is significantly higher in musical savants compared to the general population, suggesting a unique neural basis for their musical talents
  • For example, studies have reported that up to 50% of musical savants have absolute pitch, compared to only about 1% of the general population

Prodigious musical memory in savants

• Musical savants often demonstrate extraordinary memory abilities for music, including the capacity to memorize and reproduce complex musical pieces after a single hearing
• These individuals can store vast amounts of musical information in their long-term memory and retrieve it with remarkable accuracy and detail
• Neuroimaging studies have suggested that musical savants may have enhanced connectivity between auditory and memory-related brain regions
  • One famous example is the musical savant Leslie Lemke, who could play back a piece of music perfectly after hearing it just once, even if it was a complex classical composition

Theories on savant musical abilities

• Several theories have been proposed to explain the exceptional musical abilities observed in savant syndrome
• The enhanced perceptual functioning theory suggests that savants have heightened sensitivity and discrimination abilities in the auditory domain, allowing them to process musical information more efficiently
• The weak central coherence theory proposes that savants have a cognitive style that focuses on local details rather than global context, which may facilitate their attention to individual musical elements
• The hyper-systemizing theory posits that savants have an increased drive to analyze and understand rule-based systems, such as the patterns and structures found in music
  • These theories attempt to provide a framework for understanding the unique cognitive and neural mechanisms underlying savant musical talents

Synesthesia linking music to other senses

Chromesthesia: seeing colors from music

• Chromesthesia is a form of synesthesia in which individuals experience colors in response to musical sounds or tones
• People with chromesthesia may perceive specific colors associated with different musical notes, chords, or instruments
• The color experiences can be consistent and automatic, meaning that the same musical stimuli always evoke the same colors for a given individual
  • For instance, a person with chromesthesia might see the note "C" as red, while the note "G" is always perceived as blue

Lexical-gustatory synesthesia with musical notes

• Lexical-gustatory synesthesia is a rare form of synesthesia in which individuals experience tastes or flavors in response to words or sounds
• In some cases, musical notes or tones can trigger specific taste sensations in people with this type of synesthesia
• The taste experiences are often described as complex and realistic, similar to actually eating or drinking the associated flavor
  • For example, a person with lexical-gustatory synesthesia might taste chocolate when hearing a particular musical chord or experience the flavor of lemon when listening to a specific violin note

Neural basis of music-related synesthesia

• The neural basis of music-related synesthesia is still not fully understood, but several theories and neuroimaging studies have provided insights into the underlying mechanisms
• One hypothesis suggests that synesthesia arises from increased connectivity or cross-activation between adjacent brain regions involved in processing different sensory modalities
• Neuroimaging studies have shown that individuals with music-related synesthesia exhibit unique patterns of brain activation and connectivity compared to non-synesthetes
  • For instance, fMRI studies have demonstrated increased activation in color-processing areas of the visual cortex when synesthetes listen to music, suggesting a direct link between auditory and visual processing in their brains

Treatments utilizing music for neurological disorders

Melodic intonation therapy for aphasia

• Melodic intonation therapy (MIT) is a speech-language therapy technique that uses musical elements, such as melody and rhythm, to help individuals with aphasia recover their verbal communication skills
• MIT involves singing phrases with exaggerated pitch and rhythm, which is thought to engage right-hemisphere brain regions involved in music processing and bypass damaged left-hemisphere language areas
• Research has shown that MIT can be effective in improving speech production, fluency, and comprehension in patients with non-fluent aphasia following a stroke or brain injury
  • For example, case studies have described patients who were able to sing words and phrases that they could not speak, and gradually regained the ability to communicate through normal speech with continued MIT practice

Rhythmic auditory stimulation for Parkinson's

• Rhythmic auditory stimulation (RAS) is a music-based intervention that uses rhythmic cues, such as metronome beats or music with a strong beat, to improve motor function in individuals with Parkinson's disease (PD)
• RAS works by providing an external temporal cue that helps to regulate and synchronize movement, which is often impaired in PD due to basal ganglia dysfunction
• Studies have demonstrated that RAS can improve gait parameters, such as stride length, cadence, and velocity, as well as reduce freezing of gait episodes in PD patients
  • For instance, research has shown that PD patients who walk while listening to music with a strong beat exhibit increased stride length and arm swing compared to walking without auditory cues

Music as emotional regulation in dementia care

• Music has been increasingly recognized as a valuable tool for emotional regulation and enhancing quality of life in individuals with dementia, such as Alzheimer's disease
• Familiar music can evoke positive emotions, reduce agitation and anxiety, and promote social engagement in people with dementia
• Music therapy interventions, such as group singing, instrument playing, and personalized music listening, have been shown to improve mood, behavior, and cognitive function in dementia patients
  • For example, studies have reported that individualized music playlists, featuring songs that are meaningful and enjoyable to the patient, can reduce agitation, improve sleep, and increase social interaction in individuals with advanced dementia