7.7 Resistance to assimilation

Native Americans resisted assimilation through various means, from subtle cultural preservation to large-scale movements. These efforts aimed to maintain Indigenous identities, languages, and traditions in the face of colonial pressures and government policies.

Key resistance strategies included preserving oral traditions, conducting secret ceremonies, and establishing tribal schools. Movements like the Ghost Dance and American Indian Movement challenged federal policies, while legal battles fought for treaty rights and land claims.

Forms of resistance

• Resistance to assimilation played a crucial role in Native American history, encompassing various strategies to preserve cultural identity and autonomy
• Forms of resistance ranged from subtle, everyday acts to large-scale organized movements, reflecting the diverse approaches taken by Indigenous communities
• Understanding these forms of resistance provides insight into the resilience and adaptability of Native American cultures in the face of colonial pressures

Passive vs active resistance

Top images from around the web for Passive vs active resistance

• 

  530919_Shoshone_Indians_Ft_Washakie_Wyoming_Indian_Reserva… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Allotment Era and Resistance in the Native West | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  revolucion: Gerónimo, la última resistencia. View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  530919_Shoshone_Indians_Ft_Washakie_Wyoming_Indian_Reserva… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Allotment Era and Resistance in the Native West | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Passive vs active resistance

• 

  530919_Shoshone_Indians_Ft_Washakie_Wyoming_Indian_Reserva… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Allotment Era and Resistance in the Native West | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  revolucion: Gerónimo, la última resistencia. View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  530919_Shoshone_Indians_Ft_Washakie_Wyoming_Indian_Reserva… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Allotment Era and Resistance in the Native West | US History II (American Yawp) View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Passive resistance involved non-violent, often covert methods to maintain cultural practices
• Active resistance included open defiance, protests, and sometimes armed conflicts
• Passive resistance strategies encompassed maintaining traditional languages in private settings
• Active resistance manifested in organized protests against land encroachment or treaty violations
• Both forms often coexisted within communities, adapting to changing circumstances and threats

Cultural preservation efforts

• Oral tradition maintenance ensured the continuity of histories, legends, and cultural knowledge
• Traditional ceremonies conducted in secret to avoid persecution or interference
• Craftsmanship and artistic practices preserved as means of cultural expression and identity
• Intergenerational teaching of customs, values, and beliefs within families and communities
• Adaptation of cultural practices to new contexts while retaining core meanings and significance

Religious practices maintenance

• Continuation of spiritual ceremonies despite legal prohibitions (Sun Dance, Ghost Dance)
• Syncretism blended traditional beliefs with introduced religions to maintain cultural continuity
• Sacred objects and sites protected and maintained, often in secret
• Spiritual leaders continued to guide communities, preserving traditional knowledge and practices
• Resistance to forced conversion efforts by maintaining traditional spiritual worldviews

Key resistance movements

• Resistance movements in Native American history represented organized efforts to challenge assimilation policies and assert Indigenous rights
• These movements often emerged in response to specific threats or injustices, galvanizing communities and sometimes spanning tribal boundaries
• Understanding key resistance movements provides insight into the evolving strategies and goals of Native American resistance over time

Ghost Dance movement

• Spiritual revitalization movement originated by Wovoka, a Paiute prophet, in the late 19th century
• Promised the return of ancestral lands, buffalo herds, and deceased relatives
• Spread rapidly among various tribes, particularly in the Great Plains region
• Incorporated traditional and new religious elements, including circular dance rituals
• Perceived as a threat by U.S. authorities, leading to increased tensions and ultimately the Wounded Knee Massacre

Pueblo Revolt

• Large-scale uprising in 1680 against Spanish colonial rule in the present-day Southwest
• Led by Po'pay, a San Juan Pueblo religious leader
• Involved coordinated attacks on Spanish settlements across New Mexico
• Successfully expelled Spanish colonizers for over a decade
• Resulted in the preservation of Pueblo culture, religion, and land holdings
• Demonstrated the power of inter-tribal alliances in resisting colonial domination

American Indian Movement

• Founded in 1968 to address issues of poverty, housing, and police brutality in urban Native communities
• Expanded focus to include treaty rights, cultural preservation, and sovereignty
• Organized high-profile protests, including the occupation of Alcatraz Island (1969-1971)
• Led the Trail of Broken Treaties march to Washington D.C. in 1972
• Involved in the 71-day occupation of Wounded Knee in 1973
• Raised national and international awareness of Native American issues and rights

Resistance through education

• Education emerged as a powerful tool for resistance against assimilation policies and cultural erasure
• Native communities recognized the importance of controlling their own educational systems to preserve language, culture, and traditional knowledge
• Educational initiatives aimed to counteract the harmful effects of boarding schools and mainstream education systems on Indigenous identity

Tribal schools establishment

• Creation of community-controlled schools on reservations to provide culturally relevant education
• Incorporation of traditional knowledge, languages, and practices into curriculum
• Focus on holistic education addressing academic, cultural, and spiritual needs of Native students
• Development of Indigenous teaching methodologies and materials
• Emphasis on preparing students for success in both Native and non-Native contexts

Language preservation programs

• Implementation of immersion programs to revitalize endangered Indigenous languages
• Development of language nests for early childhood education in Native languages
• Creation of dictionaries, textbooks, and digital resources for language learning
• Training of Native language teachers and development of certification programs
• Integration of language instruction into broader cultural education initiatives

Cultural education initiatives

• Establishment of cultural centers and museums to preserve and share Indigenous knowledge
• Development of intergenerational mentorship programs to pass on traditional skills and practices
• Creation of summer camps and after-school programs focused on cultural education
• Integration of elders and knowledge keepers into formal and informal educational settings
• Use of technology to document and disseminate cultural knowledge (digital storytelling, online archives)

Legal challenges

• Legal challenges represented a significant form of resistance against assimilation policies and infringement on Native American rights
• Native communities and individuals utilized the U.S. legal system to assert their rights and challenge discriminatory practices
• Legal resistance efforts often involved complex, long-term strategies and collaborations between tribes and legal experts

Treaty rights assertion

• Litigation to enforce rights guaranteed in historical treaties with the U.S. government
• Focus on hunting, fishing, and gathering rights in ceded territories
• Challenges to state regulations that infringed on treaty-protected activities
• Efforts to clarify and expand interpretation of treaty language in modern contexts
• Use of international law and forums to support treaty rights claims

Land claim disputes

• Legal actions to reclaim ancestral lands lost through fraudulent or coerced agreements
• Challenges to the legality of past land cessions and boundary disputes
• Efforts to secure compensation for illegally taken lands
• Use of historical documentation and oral traditions to support land claims
• Negotiation of land returns or alternative compensation agreements

Sovereignty recognition efforts

• Legal challenges to assert and protect tribal sovereignty and self-governance rights
• Efforts to clarify and expand tribal jurisdiction over reservation lands and members
• Resistance to state attempts to impose taxes or regulations on tribal territories
• Advocacy for government-to-government relationships between tribes and federal agencies
• Use of federal Indian law principles to support tribal sovereignty in court cases

Economic resistance strategies

• Economic resistance strategies emerged as a crucial aspect of Native American efforts to maintain autonomy and self-sufficiency
• These strategies aimed to reduce dependence on federal support and create sustainable economic bases for tribal communities
• Economic initiatives often combined traditional practices with modern business approaches to create uniquely Indigenous economic models

Tribal business development

• Establishment of tribally-owned enterprises to generate revenue and employment opportunities
• Development of diverse business portfolios including manufacturing, tourism, and technology sectors
• Creation of economic development corporations to manage tribal business interests
• Implementation of preferential hiring practices for tribal members
• Use of profits to fund social services, education, and cultural preservation programs

Casino gaming initiatives

• Leveraging of tribal sovereignty to establish gaming operations on reservation lands
• Negotiation of tribal-state compacts to regulate and tax casino operations
• Use of casino revenues to fund tribal government operations and community development projects
• Development of associated hospitality and entertainment industries
• Implementation of responsible gaming practices and addiction prevention programs

Natural resource management

• Assertion of tribal control over natural resources on reservation lands
• Development of sustainable resource extraction and management practices
• Creation of tribal environmental protection agencies and regulations
• Negotiation of resource-sharing agreements with federal and state governments
• Use of traditional ecological knowledge in conservation and resource management efforts

Pan-Indian resistance

• Pan-Indian resistance movements emerged as a response to shared experiences of colonization and assimilation across diverse Native American tribes
• These movements sought to unite Indigenous peoples beyond tribal boundaries to address common challenges and advocate for collective rights
• Pan-Indian activism played a crucial role in shaping national policies and raising awareness of Native American issues

Inter-tribal alliances formation

• Creation of regional and national coalitions to address shared concerns and goals
• Development of inter-tribal governance structures and decision-making processes
• Collaboration on legal challenges and policy advocacy efforts
• Sharing of resources, knowledge, and strategies across tribal communities
• Organization of joint cultural events and gatherings to strengthen pan-Indian identity

National advocacy organizations

• Establishment of organizations like the National Congress of American Indians (NCAI) in 1944
• Creation of issue-specific groups focusing on education, health, or environmental concerns
• Development of Native-led think tanks and policy institutes
• Formation of professional associations for Native American lawyers, educators, and other professionals
• Coordination of national campaigns and lobbying efforts on behalf of Native American interests

Urban Indian activism

• Organization of urban Native communities to address unique challenges faced off-reservation
• Establishment of urban Indian centers to provide cultural and social services
• Development of pan-Indian identities and cultural practices in urban settings
• Creation of urban Native youth programs and educational initiatives
• Advocacy for recognition and support of urban Native populations in federal Indian policies

Artistic and literary resistance

• Artistic and literary forms of resistance emerged as powerful tools for preserving and asserting Native American cultural identity
• These creative expressions challenged stereotypes, reclaimed narratives, and provided platforms for Indigenous voices
• Artistic and literary resistance often bridged traditional and contemporary forms, demonstrating the adaptability and resilience of Native cultures

Native American literature

• Emergence of Native American authors writing in English to reach broader audiences
• Use of storytelling traditions and oral histories in written works
• Exploration of themes of identity, colonization, and cultural survival in novels and poetry
• Development of Native American literary criticism and theory
• Creation of publishing houses and literary journals dedicated to Indigenous voices

Traditional art forms revival

• Revitalization of traditional crafts such as pottery, weaving, and beadwork
• Preservation and innovation in traditional dance and music forms
• Continuation of ceremonial art practices within tribal communities
• Teaching of traditional art techniques to younger generations
• Use of traditional art forms in contemporary contexts and markets

Contemporary Native art

• Integration of traditional elements with modern artistic techniques and media
• Use of art to comment on social and political issues affecting Native communities
• Development of Native-run galleries, museums, and art markets
• Exploration of themes of identity, history, and spirituality in visual arts
• Incorporation of Indigenous perspectives in film, photography, and digital media

Environmental resistance

• Environmental resistance emerged as a significant aspect of Native American activism, rooted in traditional relationships with the land
• These movements sought to protect sacred sites, preserve ecosystems, and assert tribal rights in environmental decision-making
• Environmental resistance often combined traditional ecological knowledge with modern scientific approaches

Sacred land protection

• Legal and grassroots efforts to preserve culturally significant landscapes and sites
• Resistance to development projects threatening sacred areas (mining, pipelines)
• Use of religious freedom arguments to defend access to and preservation of sacred sites
• Collaboration with environmental groups to create protected areas
• Education initiatives to raise awareness about the cultural significance of specific lands

Natural resource conservation

• Development of tribal conservation programs and wildlife management initiatives
• Restoration of traditional ecosystems and reintroduction of native species
• Implementation of sustainable harvesting practices for traditional foods and medicines
• Resistance to extractive industries and harmful land-use practices on or near tribal lands
• Use of traditional ecological knowledge in conservation and climate change adaptation efforts

Environmental justice movements

• Advocacy against disproportionate environmental impacts on Native communities
• Resistance to toxic waste dumping and pollution on or near tribal lands
• Efforts to address health impacts of environmental degradation in Native communities
• Participation in global Indigenous environmental movements and forums
• Development of tribal environmental codes and enforcement mechanisms

Resistance in modern era

• Modern forms of resistance have adapted to new technologies and global contexts while maintaining connections to traditional values and goals
• These contemporary resistance strategies often leverage digital platforms and international networks to amplify Native voices and concerns
• Modern resistance efforts continue to address historical injustices while also engaging with emerging challenges and opportunities

Digital activism

• Use of social media platforms to organize protests and raise awareness (NoDAPL movement)
• Creation of online communities and forums for sharing information and strategies
• Development of digital archives and databases to preserve cultural knowledge
• Use of crowdfunding platforms to support Indigenous-led initiatives and legal challenges
• Creation of Indigenous-focused podcasts, YouTube channels, and streaming content

Social media campaigns

• Hashtag activism to bring attention to Native issues (#MMIW, #LandBack)
• Viral challenges and trends promoting Indigenous culture and language
• Use of memes and humor to critique stereotypes and misconceptions
• Live-streaming of protests, ceremonies, and cultural events
• Coordination of online and offline actions through social media organizing

Indigenous rights advocacy

• Engagement with international bodies like the United Nations on Indigenous rights issues
• Participation in global climate change discussions and initiatives
• Advocacy for implementation of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples
• Collaboration with Indigenous groups worldwide on shared concerns and strategies
• Use of international legal frameworks to support sovereignty and self-determination claims

Impacts of resistance

• The cumulative effects of various forms of Native American resistance have led to significant changes in policies, cultural perceptions, and Indigenous empowerment
• These impacts demonstrate the effectiveness of sustained resistance efforts and the resilience of Native American communities
• Understanding the impacts of resistance provides insight into ongoing challenges and opportunities for Indigenous rights and cultural revitalization

Policy changes

• Passage of legislation protecting Native American religious freedom and cultural practices
• Reforms in federal Indian policy, including self-determination and self-governance initiatives
• Establishment of government-to-government consultation requirements for federal agencies
• Creation of programs and funding streams specifically for Native American needs
• Improvements in treaty rights enforcement and interpretation

Cultural revitalization

• Resurgence of traditional languages through community-based learning programs
• Revival of cultural practices and ceremonies previously suppressed or forgotten
• Increased pride and identification with Native heritage, especially among youth
• Growth of Native-controlled educational institutions and culturally relevant curricula
• Expansion of Native American studies programs in mainstream universities

Societal awareness increase

• Greater public understanding of Native American history, cultures, and contemporary issues
• Improved representation of Native Americans in media, literature, and popular culture
• Increased recognition of Native American contributions to science, art, and society
• Growing support for Indigenous rights and causes among non-Native allies
• Shift in historical narratives to include Indigenous perspectives and experiences