7.2 Taxes and Subsidies

Taxes and subsidies are powerful tools governments use to shape markets and behavior. They can shift supply and demand, alter prices and quantities, and impact overall market efficiency. Understanding their effects is crucial for grasping how governments intervene in economies.

The distribution of tax burdens and subsidy benefits depends on market elasticities and structures. Policymakers must carefully design these interventions to achieve their goals, considering factors like target populations and potential unintended consequences. Evaluating their effectiveness is key to informed economic policy.

Taxes and subsidies on markets

Impact on market equilibrium

Top images from around the web for Impact on market equilibrium

• 

  Elasticity and Pricing · Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Changes in Equilibrium Price and Quantity: The Four-Step Process · Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Changes in Equilibrium Price and Quantity: The Four-Step Process | OpenStax Macroeconomics 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Elasticity and Pricing · Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Changes in Equilibrium Price and Quantity: The Four-Step Process · Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Impact on market equilibrium

• 

  Elasticity and Pricing · Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Changes in Equilibrium Price and Quantity: The Four-Step Process · Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Changes in Equilibrium Price and Quantity: The Four-Step Process | OpenStax Macroeconomics 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Elasticity and Pricing · Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Changes in Equilibrium Price and Quantity: The Four-Step Process · Economics View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Taxes and subsidies alter equilibrium price and quantity by shifting supply or demand curves
• Taxes increase production or consumption costs, shifting supply curve upward or demand curve downward
• Subsidies decrease production or consumption costs, shifting supply curve downward or demand curve upward
• Taxes generally lead to higher consumer prices and lower quantities traded (gasoline taxes)
• Subsidies typically result in lower consumer prices and higher quantities traded (agricultural subsidies)
• Impact magnitude depends on supply and demand elasticities in the market
  • More elastic curves lead to larger quantity changes
  • Less elastic curves lead to larger price changes

Effects on market efficiency

• Taxes create deadweight loss, reducing overall market efficiency
  • Deadweight loss represents lost consumer and producer surplus
  • Size of deadweight loss increases with tax rate and market elasticities
• Subsidies may create inefficiencies through overproduction or overconsumption
  • Example: Farm subsidies leading to excess crop production
• Both taxes and subsidies can distort market signals and resource allocation
• In some cases, taxes or subsidies can improve efficiency by addressing externalities
  • Carbon taxes to reduce pollution
  • Subsidies for renewable energy research

Incidence of taxes and subsidies

Burden distribution

• Tax incidence refers to distribution of tax burden between consumers and producers
• Economic incidence often differs from legal incidence of the tax
• Subsidy incidence follows similar principles for benefit distribution
• Relative elasticities of supply and demand determine incidence
  • Inelastic demand compared to supply: consumers bear larger share (cigarette taxes)
  • Inelastic supply compared to demand: producers bear larger share (property taxes)
• Tax shifting occurs when burden passes from legally imposed party to other participants
  • Example: Businesses passing sales tax to consumers through higher prices

Factors affecting incidence

• Market structure influences tax and subsidy incidence
  • Perfectly competitive markets may have different long-run vs. short-run effects
  • Monopolistic markets may absorb more of the tax burden
• Time horizon affects incidence as market adjusts
  • Short-run: limited ability to shift burden
  • Long-run: greater flexibility in production and consumption decisions
• Government policies can impact incidence
  • Price controls may prevent full passing of taxes to consumers
  • Trade policies can affect international tax incidence

Effectiveness of taxes and subsidies

Policy objectives and design

• Taxes and subsidies address market failures, redistribute income, or influence behavior
• Pigouvian taxes internalize negative externalities (carbon taxes)
• Subsidies encourage positive externalities or support strategic industries (renewable energy subsidies)
• Effectiveness depends on accurate policy design and implementation
• Policymakers must consider:
  • Target population or market segment
  • Appropriate tax rate or subsidy amount
  • Timing and duration of the intervention
  • Potential unintended consequences

Evaluation methods

• Cost-benefit analysis assesses overall impact of tax and subsidy policies
• Empirical studies measure actual effects on market outcomes
• Key metrics for evaluation:
  • Changes in prices and quantities
  • Distributional effects across different groups
  • Environmental or social impacts
  • Administrative costs and efficiency
• Challenges in evaluation:
  • Isolating policy effects from other market factors
  • Accounting for long-term behavioral changes
  • Measuring non-market costs and benefits

Taxes vs subsidies on markets

Types of taxes

• Ad valorem taxes proportional to good's price (sales tax)
• Specific (per-unit) taxes fixed amount per unit (gasoline tax)
• Progressive taxes increase with income (income tax brackets)
• Regressive taxes decrease as percentage of income as income rises (flat sales tax)
• Proportional taxes maintain constant percentage across income levels (flat income tax)
• Broad-based taxes apply to wide range of goods or activities (VAT)
• Narrow taxes target specific goods or industries (sin taxes on alcohol)

Types of subsidies

• Direct producer subsidies provide payments to producers (farm subsidies)
• Consumer-oriented subsidies reduce costs for buyers (housing subsidies)
• Tax credits reduce tax liability for specific activities (electric vehicle tax credits)
• Price supports maintain minimum prices for goods (agricultural price floors)
• Research and development subsidies support innovation (grants for medical research)

Comparative effects

• Ad valorem vs. specific taxes have different impacts on price elasticity of demand
• Direct subsidies to producers vs. consumer subsidies affect market differently
  • Producer subsidies may lead to overproduction
  • Consumer subsidies may increase demand without affecting supply
• Temporary vs. permanent interventions lead to different short-term and long-term outcomes
  • Temporary tax cuts may have limited impact on long-term behavior
  • Permanent subsidies can reshape entire industries over time
• Multiple taxes or subsidies in a market can have compounded or offsetting effects
  • Example: Simultaneous luxury tax and production subsidy on electric vehicles