8.4 Electoral reform and its constitutional implications

Electoral reform in the UK is a hot topic, with calls to ditch First Past the Post for more proportional systems. Supporters say it'd make voting fairer and give smaller parties a shot. But critics worry it could lead to unstable coalitions and weaken MP-constituency links.

Changing how we vote could shake up how power works in Parliament. We might see more coalitions, a more diverse House of Commons, and shifts in how the PM and parties operate. It could even impact devolution and spark debates about codifying parts of the constitution.

Electoral Reform Arguments

Proportional Representation and Alternative Vote Systems

Top images from around the web for Proportional Representation and Alternative Vote Systems

• 

  2011 United Kingdom Alternative Vote referendum - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  UK 2010 election: What if proportional representation had … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  UK 2010 election: What if the d'Hondt electoral system had… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  2011 United Kingdom Alternative Vote referendum - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  UK 2010 election: What if proportional representation had … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Proportional Representation and Alternative Vote Systems

• 

  2011 United Kingdom Alternative Vote referendum - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  UK 2010 election: What if proportional representation had … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  UK 2010 election: What if the d'Hondt electoral system had… | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  2011 United Kingdom Alternative Vote referendum - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  UK 2010 election: What if proportional representation had … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Electoral reform changes the system used to elect representatives
  • UK currently uses First Past the Post (FPTP) for general elections
• Proportional Representation (PR) allocates seats proportionally to votes cast
  • Variations include party list systems and Single Transferable Vote (STV)
• Alternative Vote (AV) allows voters to rank candidates by preference
  • Can lead to more representative outcomes than FPTP
• Arguments for reform
  • Increased fairness in representation
  • Better representation of minority parties
  • Reduced likelihood of 'wasted' votes (votes for losing candidates)
• Arguments against reform
  • Potential for coalition governments seen as less stable
  • Loss of clear constituency link provided by FPTP

Critiques of Current System

• Critics argue FPTP leads to disproportionate results
  • Party's share of seats often doesn't reflect national vote share
• FPTP supporters claim it produces strong, stable governments
  • Maintains clear link between MPs and constituencies
• Public opinion on electoral reform fluctuates
  • Often influenced by recent election results
  • Perceived fairness of outcomes impacts views

Impact on Power Balance

Changes to Government Formation

• Electoral reform could increase coalition or minority governments
  • May weaken executive's ability to implement agenda without compromise
• Proportional systems could result in more diverse Parliament
  • Smaller parties gain representation and influence legislative process
• Reform might alter Prime Minister-party relationship
  • PM autonomy potentially reduced if reliant on coalition partners
  • Slim majorities could necessitate more negotiation

Shifts in Parliamentary Dynamics

• Reform could strengthen Parliament's scrutiny function
  • More diverse chamber less likely to have overwhelming government majority
• Changes to parliamentary procedures may be necessary
  • Confidence votes and government formation processes could be affected
• Whip system power potentially diminished in proportional system
  • Could lead to more independent voting by MPs
• Traditional two-party dominance may be altered
  • Changes dynamics of opposition and government formation

Implications for Constitution

Impact on Governing Institutions

• House of Lords composition and powers may need review
  • Ensure complementarity with potentially more diverse Commons
• Monarchy's role in appointing Prime Minister could become more complex
  • Coalition negotiations may become more frequent
• Codification of certain constitutional practices may be necessary
  • Provide clarity in more complex political landscapes
• Balance between direct democracy and representative democracy could shift
  • Affects how major constitutional changes are decided (referendums)

Effects on Devolution and Regional Governance

• Relationship between Westminster and devolved administrations may change
  • Different electoral systems at different government levels could cause tension
• Reform could influence debates on further devolution
  • May impact calls for independence in UK's constituent nations
• Experience of electoral reform in devolved administrations
  • Provides case studies for potential national implementation
  • Examples include use of Additional Member System in Scottish Parliament

Prospects for Change

Political and Public Factors

• Major political parties' stances crucial to reform prospects
  • Some historically benefit from current FPTP system
• Pressure groups and cross-party alliances play significant role
  • Impact public and political discourse on reform
• Constitutional conventions influence implementation process
  • Use of referendums for major changes may be required
  • AV referendum in 2011 resulted in rejection of change

Practical Considerations

• Complexity of implementing reform affects likelihood and timeline
  • Logistical challenges in changing voting systems
  • Educational needs to inform public about new system
• International comparisons inform UK reform debates
  • Experiences of countries like New Zealand (Mixed Member Proportional system)
• Local government electoral reform experiences provide insights
  • Use of STV in Scottish local elections since 2007