8.1 Gender roles and identity in Twelfth Night

Gender roles and identity play a crucial part in Twelfth Night. The play explores how characters navigate societal expectations, often challenging norms through disguise and behavior. This creates a complex web of relationships and misunderstandings.

Viola's disguise as Cesario is central to the plot, blurring lines between masculine and feminine traits. Other characters also subvert traditional roles, highlighting the performative nature of gender and questioning societal norms of the time.

Gender Roles in Twelfth Night

Elizabethan Gender Norms and Expectations

Top images from around the web for Elizabethan Gender Norms and Expectations

• 

  Twelfth Night | Victorian Illustrated Shakespeare Archive View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Malvolio and Viola | Victorian Illustrated Shakespeare Archive View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Twelfth Night | Victorian Illustrated Shakespeare Archive View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Twelfth Night | Victorian Illustrated Shakespeare Archive View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Malvolio and Viola | Victorian Illustrated Shakespeare Archive View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Elizabethan Gender Norms and Expectations

• 

  Twelfth Night | Victorian Illustrated Shakespeare Archive View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Malvolio and Viola | Victorian Illustrated Shakespeare Archive View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Twelfth Night | Victorian Illustrated Shakespeare Archive View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Twelfth Night | Victorian Illustrated Shakespeare Archive View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Malvolio and Viola | Victorian Illustrated Shakespeare Archive View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Rigid gender norms and expectations of Elizabethan society reflected in characters and interactions
• Dichotomy between masculine and feminine traits explored through Viola/Cesario and Olivia
• Dramatic irony highlights absurdity and limitations of strict gender roles
• Marriage presented as societal expectation and ultimate goal, especially for women
• Cross-dressing serves as literary device to examine and critique gender expectations
• Malvolio embodies exaggerated masculine traits, acting as foil to explore societal expectations of men

Gender in Character Development and Relationships

• Viola/Cesario character explores performative nature of gender through disguise
• Olivia's pursuit of Cesario subverts traditional courtship norms, demonstrating female agency
• Orsino's emotional nature contradicts stereotypical masculine stoicism
• Antonio and Sebastian's relationship hints at homosocial or homoerotic bonds
• Maria's wit and scheming abilities defy notion of women as passive figures
• Feste, as fool, exists outside traditional gender expectations, allowing societal commentary

Challenging Gender Norms

Characters Subverting Traditional Roles

• Viola adopts male persona (Cesario) to navigate male-dominated spaces
  • Allows her to serve as a page in Orsino's court
  • Enables her to act as a messenger between Orsino and Olivia
• Olivia actively pursues Cesario, inverting traditional courtship dynamics
  • Sends tokens of affection (ring) to Cesario
  • Proposes marriage to Sebastian (believing him to be Cesario)
• Orsino displays emotional vulnerability, contradicting masculine stereotypes
  • Openly expresses his lovesickness for Olivia
  • Forms deep emotional bond with Cesario

Challenging Societal Expectations

• Maria demonstrates intellectual prowess and agency
  • Devises the plot against Malvolio
  • Rises above her social station through marriage to Sir Toby
• Antonio's devotion to Sebastian suggests non-heteronormative relationships
  • Risks arrest to follow Sebastian to Illyria
  • Expresses deep emotional attachment to Sebastian
• Feste's role as fool allows critique of gender norms
  • Uses wit and wordplay to comment on characters' behavior
  • Moves freely between households, transcending typical gender-based restrictions

Gender Fluidity and Ambiguity

Viola/Cesario as Central Example

• Viola's disguise as Cesario creates fluid gender identity driving plot
  • Attracts both Olivia and Orsino, blurring sexual orientation lines
  • Navigates male spaces while retaining feminine sensibilities
• Dramatic irony in Viola/Cesario scenes explores performative nature of gender
  • Audience aware of true identity while characters remain oblivious
  • Highlights arbitrary nature of gender-based behavior expectations

Challenging Binary Gender Understanding

• Attraction between Olivia and Viola/Cesario blurs heteronormative relationships
  • Olivia falls in love with Cesario's feminine qualities in a male form
  • Questions the basis of attraction and love beyond physical appearance
• Sebastian as foil to Viola/Cesario highlights constructed nature of gender performance
  • Identical twins of opposite genders cause confusion and mistaken identities
  • Demonstrates how gender is perceived through external presentation
• Play's resolution comments on societal need for fixed gender categories
  • Viola's revelation of true identity restores order
  • Marriages at end reinforce heteronormative expectations while questioning their validity

Gender and Power Dynamics

Gender Influence on Social Status

• Viola's experiences as Cesario reveal gender's impact on authority
  • Gains access to male-dominated spaces and conversations
  • Treated with more respect and given more responsibility as a man
• Orsino's interactions with Viola/Cesario reveal homosocial nature of male friendships
  • Confides in Cesario more openly than other male courtiers
  • Demonstrates intimacy possible in male-male relationships of the time

Intersections of Gender, Class, and Power

• Olivia's status as wealthy, independent woman allows her to exercise traditionally male power
  • Manages her own household and makes decisions independently
  • Rejects suitors at will, including a duke
• Sir Toby and Maria's relationship demonstrates intersection of class and gender in power dynamics
  • Maria's wit allows her to manipulate those of higher social status
  • Their marriage represents a crossing of class boundaries
• Malvolio's adherence to rigid gender norms leads to social downfall
  • His exaggerated masculinity and ambition make him a target for ridicule
  • Demonstrates dangers of inflexibility in gender performance