8.1 Theories of beauty and taste

Theories of beauty and taste have shaped art criticism throughout history. From ancient Greek philosophers to modern thinkers, debates on what makes art beautiful have influenced how we evaluate and interpret artwork.

These theories explore the tension between objective and subjective views of beauty. They consider how cultural values, social norms, and historical context impact our perception of beauty in art. Understanding these ideas is key to grasping art criticism's evolution.

Beauty and Taste in Art Criticism

Historical Development of Theories

Top images from around the web for Historical Development of Theories

• 

  Greek Philosophers - Aristotle - Democritus - Socrates - Pythagoras View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Raphael School of Athens.jpg - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Philosopher - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Greek Philosophers - Aristotle - Democritus - Socrates - Pythagoras View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Raphael School of Athens.jpg - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Historical Development of Theories

• 

  Greek Philosophers - Aristotle - Democritus - Socrates - Pythagoras View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Raphael School of Athens.jpg - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Philosopher - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Greek Philosophers - Aristotle - Democritus - Socrates - Pythagoras View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Raphael School of Athens.jpg - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Ancient Greek philosophers (Plato, Aristotle) laid the foundation for the study of aesthetics and the nature of beauty
  • Plato argued beauty exists in an ideal realm
  • Aristotle focused on formal properties of objects that make them beautiful
• Renaissance theorists (Leon Battista Alberti, Giorgio Vasari) emphasized importance of proportion, harmony, and imitation of nature in defining beauty
• 18th-century philosophers (David Hume, Immanuel Kant) developed influential theories of aesthetic taste and judgment
  • Emphasized role of subjective experience and universality of aesthetic principles
• Romantic movement (late 18th and early 19th centuries) challenged classical notions of beauty
  • Emphasized importance of emotion, imagination, and individual expression
• Modern and contemporary art movements (Impressionism, Cubism, Abstract Expressionism) expanded boundaries of what is considered beautiful
  • Often rejected traditional standards of representation and harmony

Implications for Art Criticism

• Debate influences how we evaluate and interpret works of art
• Affects understanding of the role of the artist and viewer in creating and appreciating beauty
• Raises questions about the nature of aesthetic value and the influence of cultural norms and expectations
• Attempts to reconcile objective and subjective theories (David Hume) argue for universal principles underlying aesthetic judgments despite varying individual tastes

Objective vs. Subjective Beauty

Objective Theories of Beauty

• Argue for universal, timeless principles defining beauty (proportion, symmetry, harmony)
• Suggest beauty is an inherent quality of the artwork, independent of individual perception or cultural context
• Examples: Classical Greek and Renaissance art emphasizing ideal proportions and balance

Subjective Theories of Beauty

• Emphasize role of individual taste, emotion, and personal experience in determining beauty
• Argue beauty is in the eye of the beholder, shaped by cultural, social, and historical factors
• Examples: Romantic and modern art movements valuing individual expression and challenging traditional standards

Reconciling Objective and Subjective Theories

• Some philosophers (David Hume) attempt to reconcile the two perspectives
• Argue for universal principles underlying aesthetic judgments despite varying individual tastes
• Suggest refined taste develops through experience, comparison, and elimination of prejudice
• Propose joint verdict of true judges can serve as a standard of taste

Cultural Influence on Beauty

Cultural Values and Traditions

• Significantly shape perception and appreciation of beauty in art
• Some cultures prioritize religious or symbolic content, others emphasize formal qualities or individual expression
• Examples: Islamic art focusing on intricate patterns and calligraphy, Western art historically valuing realistic representation

Social Norms and Expectations

• Gender roles, class distinctions, and political ideologies influence art creation, display, and interpretation
• Affect notions of beauty and taste
• Examples: Changing depictions of female beauty throughout history, art as propaganda reflecting political values

Historical Context

• Aesthetic standards and preferences change over time in response to social, political, and technological developments
• Plays crucial role in shaping perception of beauty
• Examples: Shift from idealized forms in Classical and Renaissance art to experimenting with perspective and light in Baroque art

Globalization and Cultural Relativism

• Exposure to diverse cultural traditions leads to greater appreciation of cultural relativism in aesthetic judgments
• Challenges the idea of universal standards of beauty
• Raises questions about the role of art in society and power dynamics between artists, critics, and audiences
• Examples: Growing recognition of non-Western art traditions, postcolonial critiques of Eurocentric beauty standards

Theories of Aesthetic Taste

David Hume's Theory of Taste

• Argues for universal principles underlying aesthetic judgments despite varying individual tastes
• Suggests refined taste develops through experience, comparison, and elimination of prejudice
• Proposes joint verdict of true judges can serve as a standard of taste
• Outlined in "Of the Standard of Taste"

Immanuel Kant's Theory of Aesthetic Judgment

• Emphasizes subjective nature of aesthetic experience
• Argues judgments of beauty based on feeling of pleasure from free play of imagination and understanding
• Distinguishes between the beautiful and the sublime
• Suggests aesthetic judgments are universally valid despite subjective basis
• Presented in "Critique of Judgment"

Edmund Burke's Theory of the Sublime

• Focuses on emotional impact of art and distinction between the beautiful and the sublime
• Associates sublime with feelings of terror, awe, and astonishment
• Characterizes beautiful as involving pleasure, smallness, and smoothness
• Outlined in "A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful"

Arthur Schopenhauer's Aesthetic Theory

• Emphasizes role of art in providing relief from constant striving of the will
• Argues aesthetic experience allows transcendence of individual self and sense of unity with the world
• Considers music the highest art form for directly expressing the will
• Presented in "The World as Will and Representation"