9.2 Acid mine drainage

Acid mine drainage plagues Appalachian coal mining regions, harming water quality and ecosystems. It occurs when sulfide minerals in coal seams are exposed to air and water, generating acidity and releasing toxic metals into nearby water sources.

This environmental issue has far-reaching impacts on Appalachian communities, affecting drinking water, health, and local economies. Prevention and mitigation strategies, along with regulatory efforts, aim to address the problem, but challenges persist in dealing with this long-lasting legacy of coal mining.

Causes of acid mine drainage

• Acid mine drainage is a major environmental issue in Appalachian coal mining regions, resulting from the exposure of sulfide minerals to air and water
• The oxidation of these minerals, particularly pyrite, generates acidity and releases dissolved metals into nearby water sources
• The presence of water and oxygen is essential for the chemical reactions that lead to acid mine drainage formation

Sulfide minerals in coal seams

Top images from around the web for Sulfide minerals in coal seams

• 

  Acid Mine Drainage | Along Yellow Spring trail. | Joey Klein | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Sulfate-Reducing Bacteria as an Effective Tool for Sustainable Acid Mine Bioremediation View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  acid mine drainage in upper Blackfoot | Credit: Earthworks. … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Acid Mine Drainage | Along Yellow Spring trail. | Joey Klein | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Sulfate-Reducing Bacteria as an Effective Tool for Sustainable Acid Mine Bioremediation View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Sulfide minerals in coal seams

• 

  Acid Mine Drainage | Along Yellow Spring trail. | Joey Klein | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Sulfate-Reducing Bacteria as an Effective Tool for Sustainable Acid Mine Bioremediation View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  acid mine drainage in upper Blackfoot | Credit: Earthworks. … | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Acid Mine Drainage | Along Yellow Spring trail. | Joey Klein | Flickr View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Sulfate-Reducing Bacteria as an Effective Tool for Sustainable Acid Mine Bioremediation View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Coal seams in Appalachia often contain sulfide minerals, such as pyrite (iron sulfide), which are stable when buried underground
• When coal is mined, these sulfide minerals are exposed to air and water, initiating the acid-generating oxidation process
• The disturbance of rock layers during mining accelerates the weathering of sulfide minerals and increases the potential for acid mine drainage

Oxidation of pyrite

• Pyrite (FeS2) is the most common sulfide mineral associated with coal seams in Appalachia
• When exposed to oxygen and water, pyrite undergoes a series of oxidation reactions that produce sulfuric acid (H2SO4) and dissolved iron
• The overall pyrite oxidation reaction can be summarized as: FeS2 + 15/4 O2 + 7/2 H2O → Fe(OH)3 + 2 H2SO4

Role of water and oxygen

• Water serves as a reactant and a transport medium for the products of pyrite oxidation, allowing the acid and dissolved metals to spread to nearby streams and groundwater
• Oxygen is necessary for the oxidation reactions to occur, and its availability is influenced by factors such as mine geometry, overburden characteristics, and groundwater flow
• The combination of water and oxygen creates an ideal environment for the formation and propagation of acid mine drainage in Appalachian coal mining regions

Environmental impacts

• Acid mine drainage has severe environmental consequences in Appalachia, affecting water quality, aquatic life, and overall ecosystem health
• The low pH and high metal concentrations in affected streams and rivers create toxic conditions that can persist for decades or even centuries after mining has ceased
• The environmental impacts of acid mine drainage extend beyond the immediate vicinity of the mine, as contaminated water can travel long distances and accumulate in downstream areas

Acidification of streams and rivers

• The release of sulfuric acid from pyrite oxidation lowers the pH of receiving waters, often to levels below 4.5, which is considered highly acidic
• Acidic conditions can cause the leaching of aluminum from soils and streambed sediments, further exacerbating the toxicity of the water
• The acidification of streams and rivers in Appalachia has led to the loss of sensitive aquatic species and the alteration of ecosystem functions

Heavy metal contamination

• In addition to acidity, acid mine drainage releases dissolved metals such as iron, manganese, aluminum, and trace elements like arsenic and lead into water bodies
• These metals can accumulate in stream sediments and the tissues of aquatic organisms, leading to chronic toxicity and bioaccumulation in food webs
• Heavy metal contamination poses risks to both aquatic life and human health, as some metals can be toxic even at low concentrations

Destruction of aquatic ecosystems

• The combined effects of acidification and metal toxicity can severely degrade aquatic habitats in Appalachian streams and rivers affected by acid mine drainage
• Sensitive species, such as certain fish, macroinvertebrates, and amphibians, may be eliminated from the ecosystem, while more tolerant organisms may experience reduced growth and reproduction
• The loss of key species can disrupt food webs and ecosystem processes, leading to a reduction in overall biodiversity and ecological function

Reduced biodiversity

• Acid mine drainage can create "dead zones" in Appalachian streams, where few aquatic species can survive due to the harsh chemical conditions
• The loss of sensitive species and the dominance of acid-tolerant organisms result in a significant reduction in biodiversity in affected watersheds
• Reduced biodiversity can have cascading effects on the ecosystem, altering nutrient cycling, primary production, and other essential ecological processes

Effects on Appalachian communities

• Acid mine drainage not only impacts the environment but also has significant consequences for Appalachian communities that rely on affected water resources
• The contamination of streams and groundwater can pose health risks, increase water treatment costs, and lower property values in affected areas
• The legacy of acid mine drainage contributes to the economic and social challenges faced by many Appalachian communities, particularly those with a history of coal mining

Contamination of drinking water sources

• In some Appalachian communities, streams and groundwater affected by acid mine drainage serve as sources of drinking water
• The acidity and high metal concentrations in these water sources can make them unsafe for human consumption without extensive treatment
• Contaminated drinking water can lead to various health issues, including gastrointestinal problems, neurological disorders, and increased risk of certain cancers

Health risks for residents

• Exposure to acid mine drainage through drinking water or recreational activities in affected streams can pose health risks to Appalachian residents
• Ingestion of water containing high levels of metals such as arsenic, lead, and mercury can cause acute and chronic health problems, particularly in children and vulnerable populations
• Inhalation of dust from contaminated streambed sediments or mine tailings can also contribute to respiratory issues and other health concerns

Economic costs of water treatment

• Treating water contaminated by acid mine drainage to meet drinking water standards can be a significant economic burden for Appalachian communities
• The need for specialized treatment technologies, such as chemical neutralization and metal removal, can greatly increase the cost of water treatment for municipalities and water utilities
• The long-term nature of acid mine drainage means that these treatment costs can persist for decades, straining local budgets and resources

Stigma and reduced property values

• The presence of acid mine drainage can create a stigma for affected communities, as the orange-colored streams and barren streambanks become visible reminders of the environmental degradation caused by mining
• This stigma, combined with the health and economic impacts of acid mine drainage, can lead to reduced property values in affected areas
• The decline in property values can further compound the economic challenges faced by Appalachian communities, limiting their ability to attract new residents and businesses

Prevention and mitigation strategies

• Addressing the problem of acid mine drainage in Appalachia requires a combination of prevention and mitigation strategies to minimize the formation of acidic drainage and treat contaminated water
• Proper mine planning, reclamation techniques, and the use of alkaline materials can help prevent or reduce the generation of acid mine drainage
• Passive and active treatment systems, such as constructed wetlands and water treatment facilities, can be used to improve the quality of water affected by acid mine drainage

Proper mine sealing and reclamation

• Effective mine sealing and reclamation practices can help prevent the formation of acid mine drainage by limiting the exposure of sulfide minerals to oxygen and water
• Techniques such as backfilling, capping, and the use of low-permeability materials can reduce the infiltration of water and oxygen into mine voids and waste rock piles
• Proper grading and revegetation of mine sites can also help stabilize soils, reduce erosion, and minimize the exposure of acid-generating materials

Alkaline material addition

• The addition of alkaline materials, such as limestone or lime, to mine spoils and drainage channels can help neutralize the acidity generated by pyrite oxidation
• Alkaline materials react with the acidic water, raising the pH and promoting the precipitation of dissolved metals
• The incorporation of alkaline materials into mine backfill or the construction of limestone drains can provide long-term buffering capacity against acid mine drainage

Constructed wetlands for passive treatment

• Constructed wetlands can be used as a passive treatment system for acid mine drainage, utilizing the natural processes of wetland ecosystems to improve water quality
• Wetland plants, such as cattails and bulrushes, can uptake and store metals in their tissues, while anaerobic bacteria in the wetland substrate can reduce sulfate and generate alkalinity
• Properly designed and maintained constructed wetlands can provide a cost-effective and low-maintenance option for treating acid mine drainage in Appalachian watersheds

Active water treatment facilities

• In some cases, the severity of acid mine drainage may require the use of active water treatment facilities to meet water quality standards
• Active treatment involves the use of chemicals, such as lime or sodium hydroxide, to neutralize acidity and remove dissolved metals through precipitation and filtration
• While active treatment can be effective in improving water quality, it requires ongoing operation and maintenance, as well as the management of the resulting metal-rich sludge

Regulatory efforts and challenges

• Efforts to address acid mine drainage in Appalachia are guided by federal and state regulations aimed at minimizing the environmental impacts of coal mining
• The Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act (SMCRA) of 1977 established requirements for mine reclamation and bonding to ensure that funds are available for long-term treatment
• Despite these regulatory efforts, challenges such as insufficient bonding, the legacy of abandoned mines, and the lack of accountability for older mining operations continue to hinder progress in addressing acid mine drainage

Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act

• SMCRA is the primary federal law regulating the environmental effects of coal mining in the United States, including provisions related to acid mine drainage
• The act requires mine operators to obtain permits, follow reclamation standards, and post bonds to cover the costs of reclamation and long-term treatment
• SMCRA also established the Abandoned Mine Land (AML) program to reclaim and restore land and water resources affected by mining operations prior to the act's passage in 1977

Abandoned Mine Land program

• The AML program, funded by a fee on active coal mining operations, provides grants to states and tribes for the reclamation of abandoned mine sites
• Priority is given to sites that pose a threat to public health, safety, and the environment, including those with acid mine drainage
• While the AML program has made progress in reclaiming abandoned mines, the scale of the problem and the limited funds available mean that many sites remain unaddressed

Insufficient bonding for long-term treatment

• One of the challenges in addressing acid mine drainage is ensuring that adequate funds are available for long-term water treatment, which may be needed for decades or even centuries after mining has ceased
• In some cases, the bonds posted by mine operators under SMCRA may be insufficient to cover the full costs of long-term treatment, leaving taxpayers to bear the burden
• Inadequate bonding can lead to a lack of resources for addressing acid mine drainage at legacy mines and can hinder efforts to restore affected watersheds

Lack of accountability for legacy mines

• Many of the mines contributing to acid mine drainage in Appalachia were operated before the passage of SMCRA and other modern environmental regulations
• In some cases, the companies responsible for these legacy mines no longer exist or cannot be held accountable for the ongoing environmental impacts
• The lack of clear responsibility and funding for addressing acid mine drainage at these sites can complicate efforts to improve water quality and restore affected ecosystems

Appalachian case studies

• Acid mine drainage affects numerous watersheds throughout the Appalachian region, with each case presenting unique challenges and opportunities for restoration
• Case studies of affected watersheds, such as the Cheat River in West Virginia and Shamokin Creek in Pennsylvania, illustrate the severity of the problem and the efforts being made to address it
• While some successes have been achieved through restoration projects and partnerships, many Appalachian communities continue to struggle with the ongoing impacts of acid mine drainage

Cheat River watershed in West Virginia

• The Cheat River watershed, located in northern West Virginia, has been heavily impacted by acid mine drainage from both abandoned and active coal mines
• The river's main stem and several tributaries, such as Muddy Creek and Greens Run, have experienced severe acidification and metal contamination, leading to the loss of aquatic life and recreational opportunities
• Restoration efforts in the watershed have included the installation of passive treatment systems, limestone sand additions, and the reclamation of abandoned mine lands

Shamokin Creek in Pennsylvania

• Shamokin Creek, a tributary of the Susquehanna River in eastern Pennsylvania, has been impacted by acid mine drainage from anthracite coal mining operations dating back to the 19th century
• The creek's water quality has been severely degraded, with low pH levels and high concentrations of metals such as iron, aluminum, and manganese
• Efforts to restore Shamokin Creek have involved the construction of passive treatment systems, including aerobic wetlands and anoxic limestone drains, as well as stream channel restoration and reforestation projects

North Fork of the Kentucky River

• The North Fork of the Kentucky River, which flows through the coalfields of eastern Kentucky, has been impacted by acid mine drainage from both surface and underground mines
• The river and its tributaries have experienced acidification, metal contamination, and the loss of aquatic life, affecting both the ecosystem and the local communities that rely on the river for water supply and recreation
• Restoration efforts in the watershed have included the installation of passive treatment systems, the use of alkaline materials to neutralize acidity, and the reclamation of abandoned mine lands

Successes and ongoing struggles

• While case studies of acid mine drainage in Appalachia demonstrate the challenges faced by affected watersheds, they also highlight the successes achieved through restoration efforts and partnerships
• In some cases, such as the Cheat River watershed, improvements in water quality and the return of aquatic life have been observed following the implementation of treatment systems and reclamation projects
• However, the scale and complexity of the acid mine drainage problem in Appalachia mean that many watersheds continue to struggle with ongoing contamination and the need for long-term treatment and monitoring
• Addressing the legacy of acid mine drainage in the region will require sustained efforts, adequate funding, and the collaboration of stakeholders, including government agencies, local communities, and conservation organizations