9.3 Identifying and fixing plot holes

Fixing plot holes is crucial for creating a compelling screenplay. It's about maintaining the story's logic and keeping viewers engaged. Without addressing these issues, even the most exciting narratives can fall flat.

Identifying and resolving plot holes involves careful analysis and creative problem-solving. From timeline inconsistencies to character motivations, writers must scrutinize every aspect of their script to ensure a cohesive and believable story unfolds.

Plot Holes and Screenplay Coherence

Understanding Plot Holes

Top images from around the web for Understanding Plot Holes

• 

  A model of suspense for narrative generation - ACL Anthology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Movie Plot Analysis via Turning Point Identification - ACL Anthology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  In the classroom: Percy's Complication View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A model of suspense for narrative generation - ACL Anthology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Movie Plot Analysis via Turning Point Identification - ACL Anthology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Understanding Plot Holes

• 

  A model of suspense for narrative generation - ACL Anthology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Movie Plot Analysis via Turning Point Identification - ACL Anthology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  In the classroom: Percy's Complication View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  A model of suspense for narrative generation - ACL Anthology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Movie Plot Analysis via Turning Point Identification - ACL Anthology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Plot holes manifest as logical inconsistencies or gaps in a story's narrative that contradict established plot points or the internal logic of the fictional world
• Significantly undermine the credibility and immersion of a screenplay led to audience disengagement and confusion
• Indicate deeper structural issues within the screenplay (insufficient character development or poorly conceived story logic)
• Range from minor discrepancies noticed by attentive viewers to major logical flaws that fundamentally break the story's premise
• Impact on screenplay coherence directly proportional to their size and relevance to the main narrative arc
• Addressing plot holes maintains the integrity of the story world and preserves the audience's suspension of disbelief
• Negatively affect the commercial viability of a screenplay (often targeted by critics and discerning viewers)

Importance of Plot Coherence

• Crucial for maintaining narrative integrity and audience engagement
• Enhances the overall quality and professionalism of the screenplay
• Strengthens the story's emotional impact by eliminating distractions
• Improves the screenplay's chances of success in the competitive film industry
• Demonstrates the writer's attention to detail and storytelling skills
• Facilitates smoother production process by reducing the need for extensive rewrites
• Contributes to building a loyal fanbase who appreciate well-crafted, logically consistent stories

Types of Plot Holes

Narrative Inconsistencies

• Continuity errors contradict previously established details in the timeline, character appearances, or props
• Character inconsistencies involve actions or decisions that contradict established personality, motivations, or abilities
• Logical fallacies defy common sense or the established rules of the story world
• Deus ex machina introduces an unexpected power, event, or character to resolve a seemingly unsolvable problem
• Unresolved subplots leave story threads introduced but never adequately addressed or concluded

Information and Knowledge Gaps

• Unexplained character knowledge occurs when characters possess information they shouldn't logically have access to without explanation
• Plot-convenient amnesia happens when characters forget crucial information solely to serve the plot's needs
• Time paradoxes create inconsistencies in the story's chronology or cause-and-effect relationships
• Inconsistent world-building rules contradict previously established laws or norms of the fictional universe
• Unexplained character motivations leave audience questioning the reasons behind critical decisions or actions

Identifying Plot Holes

Analytical Techniques

• Conduct a chronological read-through focused solely on the logical progression of events and character decisions
• Create a detailed timeline of the story's events included off-screen actions to identify temporal inconsistencies
• Develop character profiles outlining each character's knowledge, abilities, and motivations throughout the story
• Utilize beta readers or writing groups to gain fresh perspectives and identify overlooked inconsistencies
• Employ a "devil's advocate" approach actively questioning the logic and plausibility of each major plot point and character decision
• Map out cause-and-effect relationships between key events to ensure logical consistency throughout the narrative
• Implement a cooling-off period between drafts to allow for more objective analysis of the screenplay's logic and consistency

Collaborative Review Strategies

• Organize table reads with actors to identify dialogue or action inconsistencies
• Conduct focused workshops with fellow writers to scrutinize specific plot elements or character arcs
• Utilize script analysis software to track plot threads and character development
• Create a "plot hole checklist" based on common issues in your genre or writing style
• Engage in peer review sessions with other screenwriters to gain industry-specific insights
• Consult subject matter experts for specialized knowledge areas in your screenplay (legal procedures, scientific concepts)

Fixing Plot Holes

Revision Strategies

• Revise the story's premise or rules to accommodate necessary plot elements while maintaining internal logic
• Introduce foreshadowing or additional exposition to explain seemingly inconsistent events or character actions
• Adjust character motivations or backstories to align with their actions and decisions throughout the screenplay
• Eliminate or modify subplots that create logical inconsistencies or remain unresolved
• Rewrite scenes to provide logical explanations for character knowledge or abilities that initially appeared inconsistent
• Implement a "Chekhov's gun" approach ensuring all introduced elements serve a purpose and are properly resolved
• Utilize rewrites to strengthen the cause-and-effect relationships between events enhancing overall narrative cohesion

Advanced Plot Hole Solutions

• Employ non-linear storytelling techniques to resolve temporal inconsistencies (flashbacks, parallel timelines)
• Introduce unreliable narrators or multiple perspectives to justify conflicting information
• Develop subplot interconnections to resolve seemingly unrelated story threads
• Utilize dramatic irony to explain character knowledge discrepancies
• Implement "red herrings" to misdirect audience attention from potential plot holes
• Create layered character motivations to justify seemingly inconsistent actions
• Develop a comprehensive story bible to maintain consistency in complex fictional worlds