9.2 Observed temperature trends and attribution

Global temperatures have risen about 1°C since pre-industrial times, with warming accelerating recently. This change varies globally, with land areas and higher latitudes warming faster. Urban areas experience enhanced warming due to the heat island effect.

Climate models and attribution studies help distinguish human-induced changes from natural variability. Factors like greenhouse gases, aerosols, and land-use changes are considered alongside natural influences like solar variability and volcanic eruptions.

Global and Regional Temperature Trends

Global Temperature Increase

Top images from around the web for Global Temperature Increase

• 

  Attribution of recent climate change - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to Heat a Planet? Impact of Anthropogenic Landscapes on Earth’s Albedo and Temperature View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  renewable energy Archives - Universe Today View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Attribution of recent climate change - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to Heat a Planet? Impact of Anthropogenic Landscapes on Earth’s Albedo and Temperature View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Global Temperature Increase

• 

  Attribution of recent climate change - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to Heat a Planet? Impact of Anthropogenic Landscapes on Earth’s Albedo and Temperature View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  renewable energy Archives - Universe Today View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Attribution of recent climate change - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  How to Heat a Planet? Impact of Anthropogenic Landscapes on Earth’s Albedo and Temperature View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Global mean surface temperature increased approximately 1°C since pre-industrial times
  • Warming rate accelerated in recent decades
  • Represents significant departure from long-term climate norms
• Warming trend varies across the globe
  • Land areas warm faster than oceans due to differences in heat capacity
  • Higher latitudes experience more rapid warming (Arctic amplification)
    • Caused by ice-albedo feedback and changes in atmospheric circulation
• Urban areas experience enhanced warming
  • Urban heat island effect amplifies local temperature increases
  • Results from reduced vegetation, increased heat-absorbing surfaces, and anthropogenic heat sources

Temperature Pattern Changes

• Nighttime temperatures increase more rapidly than daytime temperatures
  • Leads to decrease in diurnal temperature range
  • Impacts ecosystems and agriculture adapted to specific day-night temperature cycles
• Temperature extremes become more frequent and intense in many regions
  • Heat waves occur more often and last longer (European heatwave of 2003)
  • Warm nights increase, affecting human health and energy consumption
• Some regions experience cooling trends
  • Parts of Southern Ocean and North Atlantic show localized cooling
  • Possibly due to changes in ocean circulation patterns (weakening of Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation)

Attributing Temperature Changes

Climate Modeling and Analysis

• Climate models simulate temperature changes under different forcing scenarios
  • Include both natural and anthropogenic factors
  • Allow for isolation and quantification of individual contributions
• Detection and attribution studies compare observed temperature patterns with model simulations
  • Identify fingerprints of various climate forcings
  • Help distinguish human-induced changes from natural variability
• Statistical techniques quantify contribution of different factors to observed temperature changes
  • Optimal fingerprinting method assesses relative importance of forcings
  • Bayesian approaches provide probabilistic attribution statements

Climate Forcing Factors

• Natural factors considered in attribution studies
  • Solar variability (11-year solar cycle, long-term changes in solar output)
  • Volcanic eruptions (stratospheric aerosol injections, short-term cooling effects)
  • Internal climate variability (El Niño-Southern Oscillation, Pacific Decadal Oscillation)
• Anthropogenic factors included in analyses
  • Greenhouse gas emissions (CO2, methane, nitrous oxide)
  • Aerosol emissions (sulfates, black carbon)
  • Land-use changes (deforestation, urbanization)
  • Ozone depletion (stratospheric ozone loss, tropospheric ozone increase)
• Radiative forcing concept quantifies impact of climate drivers on Earth's energy balance
  • Measured in watts per square meter (W/m²)
  • Positive forcing leads to warming, negative forcing to cooling

Evidence for Anthropogenic Influence

Observed Warming Patterns

• Spatial and temporal patterns of observed warming consistent with greenhouse gas-induced warming
  • Greater warming over land than oceans
  • Arctic amplification aligns with model predictions
• Natural factors alone cannot explain observed warming trend
  • Solar variability and volcanic activity insufficient to account for recent rapid warming
  • Internal variability (ENSO, PDO) operates on shorter timescales
• Vertical structure of atmospheric temperature changes indicates greenhouse gas influence
  • Warming in troposphere coupled with cooling in stratosphere
  • Consistent with increased greenhouse gas concentrations trapping heat in lower atmosphere

Energy Balance and Historical Context

• Changes in Earth's energy balance measured by satellites
  • Increased energy imbalance at top of atmosphere
  • Consistent with increased greenhouse gas concentrations
• Paleoclimate records show current warming rates unprecedented in past 2000 years
  • Tree rings, ice cores, and sediment records provide long-term temperature context
  • Current warming trend far exceeds natural variability seen in past millennia
• Observed warming trend aligns with timing of increased anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions
  • Rapid temperature increase coincides with Industrial Revolution
  • Acceleration of warming in late 20th century matches surge in global emissions

Uncertainties in Temperature Attribution

Climate Variability and Data Limitations

• Internal climate variability can mask or amplify anthropogenic warming signals
  • Decadal oscillations (AMO, PDO) influence regional temperature trends
  • Complicates attribution efforts on shorter timescales
• Uncertainties in historical temperature records affect accuracy of trend analyses
  • Earlier periods and data-sparse regions (oceans, polar areas) have less reliable data
  • Adjustments for instrumental biases and changes in measurement practices introduce uncertainties

Modeling Challenges and Knowledge Gaps

• Complex interactions between climate forcings and feedbacks create attribution challenges
  • Non-linear responses and tipping points difficult to model accurately
  • Feedbacks (water vapor, cloud) amplify or dampen initial forcing effects
• Limited understanding of some climate processes introduces uncertainties in model simulations
  • Aerosol-cloud interactions poorly constrained
  • Deep ocean circulation changes not fully captured in models
• Ongoing debates regarding relative importance of different anthropogenic factors
  • Role of black carbon aerosols versus greenhouse gases in Arctic warming
  • Contribution of land-use changes to regional temperature trends
• Improving spatial and temporal resolution of climate models and observations crucial for enhancing attribution accuracy
  • Higher resolution models better capture regional climate processes
  • Expanded observational networks improve data coverage and quality