9.2 State Court Systems and Their Jurisdiction

State court systems form the backbone of the American judicial system, handling the majority of legal cases. These courts are organized into trial courts, appellate courts, and state supreme courts, each with specific roles and jurisdictions.

Understanding state court systems is crucial for grasping how justice is administered at the local level. From municipal courts handling minor offenses to state supreme courts making binding decisions, these courts shape the legal landscape for everyday citizens.

State Court Structure

Trial and Local Courts

Top images from around the web for Trial and Local Courts

• 

  U S Courts: Structure and Procedure – United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  U S Courts: Structure and Procedure – United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

Top images from around the web for Trial and Local Courts

• 

  U S Courts: Structure and Procedure – United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  U S Courts: Structure and Procedure – United States Government View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 1

• Trial courts serve as the initial venue for most legal cases
• General trial courts handle a wide range of civil and criminal matters
• Specialized trial courts focus on specific areas of law (family court, probate court)
• Local courts operate at the municipal or county level
• Municipal courts typically handle minor offenses and city ordinance violations
• County courts often have broader jurisdiction than municipal courts, handling misdemeanors and some felonies

Appellate Courts and State Supreme Courts

• Appellate courts review decisions made by lower courts
• Intermediate appellate courts exist in many states to handle the majority of appeals
• State supreme courts sit at the top of the state court hierarchy
• State supreme courts primarily hear appeals from lower appellate courts
• State supreme courts have discretionary review, choosing which cases to hear
• Decisions made by state supreme courts are binding on all lower courts within the state

Types of Jurisdiction

General and Limited Jurisdiction

• General jurisdiction courts have authority to hear a wide range of cases
• General jurisdiction courts typically handle more serious criminal cases and civil matters with higher monetary values
• Limited jurisdiction courts have authority restricted to specific types of cases
• Limited jurisdiction courts often handle less serious offenses (traffic violations, small claims)
• Some courts have subject matter jurisdiction, focusing on specific areas of law (bankruptcy court, tax court)

Concurrent and Diversity Jurisdiction

• Concurrent jurisdiction occurs when multiple courts have authority over the same case
• Concurrent jurisdiction can exist between state and federal courts or between different levels of state courts
• Parties may choose which court to file in when concurrent jurisdiction applies
• Diversity jurisdiction allows federal courts to hear cases between parties from different states
• Diversity jurisdiction requires the amount in controversy to exceed a specified threshold ($75,000 for federal courts)
• Diversity jurisdiction aims to provide a neutral forum and prevent potential bias in state courts

Judicial Processes

Removal and Appeals

• Removal refers to the process of transferring a case from state court to federal court
• Removal typically occurs when a case involves federal law or meets diversity jurisdiction requirements
• Defendants usually initiate the removal process by filing a notice of removal
• Appeals process allows parties to challenge lower court decisions
• Appellate courts review legal errors rather than retrying the entire case
• Appeals may be based on errors in the application of law or procedural mistakes

State Constitutions and Judicial Selection

• State constitutions establish the structure and powers of state courts
• State constitutions often provide greater protections for individual rights than the U.S. Constitution
• Judicial selection methods vary by state (elections, gubernatorial appointments, merit selection)
• Some states use retention elections for judges after their initial appointment
• Term lengths for judges differ among states, ranging from a few years to life tenure
• State constitutions may include provisions for judicial discipline and removal processes