9.3 Viewer Positioning and Interpretation

Viewer positioning and interpretation play a crucial role in how we experience art. Artists use techniques like breaking the fourth wall, direct address, and gaze manipulation to engage viewers and shape their responses. These methods can create intimacy, challenge perspectives, or invite participation.

The way artworks position viewers affects interpretation and emotional connection. Factors like frontal or averted gaze, oblique angles, and narrative framing guide our understanding. Our personal contexts also influence how we perceive and respond to art, leading to diverse interpretations of the same piece.

Viewer Engagement Techniques

Implied Viewer and Fourth Wall

Top images from around the web for Implied Viewer and Fourth Wall

• 

  ARTH101 (2018.A.01): The Element of Texture | Saylor Academy View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Primary Ideas: Dialogue and Breaking the Fourth Wall View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Interpretation of Social Interactions: Functional Imaging of Cognitive-Semiotic ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  ARTH101 (2018.A.01): The Element of Texture | Saylor Academy View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Primary Ideas: Dialogue and Breaking the Fourth Wall View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Implied Viewer and Fourth Wall

• 

  ARTH101 (2018.A.01): The Element of Texture | Saylor Academy View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Primary Ideas: Dialogue and Breaking the Fourth Wall View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Interpretation of Social Interactions: Functional Imaging of Cognitive-Semiotic ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  ARTH101 (2018.A.01): The Element of Texture | Saylor Academy View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Primary Ideas: Dialogue and Breaking the Fourth Wall View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Implied viewer refers to the unseen, imagined audience that the artwork addresses or assumes
• Artists can engage the implied viewer by breaking the fourth wall, the imaginary barrier between the artwork and the audience
• Breaking the fourth wall acknowledges the viewer's presence and invites them into the artwork's world (character winking at the camera)
• Fourth wall breaks can create a sense of intimacy, complicity, or shared understanding between the artwork and the viewer
• Maintaining the fourth wall positions the viewer as a passive observer, while breaking it actively engages them in the artwork's reality

Direct Address and Spectator Engagement

• Direct address occurs when a character or subject in the artwork looks directly at the viewer, making eye contact
• This technique engages the spectator by creating a sense of connection, confrontation, or demand for attention
• Direct address can evoke various emotions in the viewer, such as empathy, discomfort, or a sense of being personally addressed (Mona Lisa's gaze)
• Spectator engagement can also be achieved through other techniques that draw the viewer into the artwork
• These techniques include using relatable characters, immersive environments, or interactive elements that encourage viewer participation (video game characters addressing the player)

Gaze and Perspective

Frontal and Averted Gaze

• Frontal gaze occurs when the subject looks directly at the viewer, creating a sense of engagement or confrontation
• Frontal gaze can establish a connection between the subject and the viewer, inviting them to consider the subject's perspective or emotions
• Averted gaze, in contrast, occurs when the subject looks away from the viewer, creating a sense of disconnection or introspection
• Averted gaze can suggest the subject's internal thoughts, secrets, or a lack of engagement with the viewer (portrait with subject looking off to the side)
• The choice between frontal and averted gaze can significantly impact the viewer's interpretation and emotional response to the artwork

Oblique Angles and Viewer Positioning

• Oblique angles are achieved when the subject is depicted from a side view or at an angle, rather than straight-on
• Using oblique angles can create a sense of detachment, observational perspective, or voyeurism for the viewer
• Oblique angles can also suggest a power dynamic between the viewer and the subject, depending on the angle and framing (low angle shot making subject appear powerful)
• The viewer's positioning relative to the subject can influence their interpretation and emotional response to the artwork
• Positioning the viewer at eye level with the subject can create a sense of equality, while positioning them above or below can suggest dominance or submission

Interpretation and Positioning

Interpellation and Narrative Positioning

• Interpellation refers to the way an artwork "hails" or addresses the viewer, positioning them in relation to the subject matter
• Artworks can interpellate viewers by assigning them roles, identities, or ideological positions within the narrative or context
• Narrative positioning refers to how the artwork's structure, point of view, or framing guides the viewer's understanding and emotional engagement
• Artworks can position viewers as sympathetic to certain characters, aligned with specific values, or complicit in the events depicted (protagonist's perspective in a film)
• Interpellation and narrative positioning shape the viewer's interpretation and response to the artwork, often on a subconscious level

Contextual Interpretation and Viewer Response

• Contextual interpretation acknowledges that viewers bring their own experiences, knowledge, and cultural background to their understanding of an artwork
• Viewers' personal contexts can influence their emotional response, identification with characters, or perception of the artwork's meaning
• Artworks can be interpreted differently based on the viewer's social, historical, or cultural context (religious iconography interpreted differently by believers and non-believers)
• Artists may intentionally create works that are open to multiple interpretations, inviting viewers to bring their own perspectives to the piece
• Contextual interpretation highlights the active role of the viewer in constructing meaning and the potential for diverse responses to the same artwork