1.10 Impact of social movements on policy and culture

Social movements are powerful forces that shape society through collective action. They challenge existing power structures and norms, using various strategies to push for change. From protests to policy advocacy, movements aim to shift public opinion and transform institutions.

Movements can have far-reaching impacts on culture, laws, and social norms. While they face many challenges, successful movements can lead to lasting changes in how we think and live. Understanding social movements is key to grasping how societies evolve over time.

Social movements overview

• Social movements are collective efforts by groups of people to bring about or resist social, political, economic, or cultural change
• They involve organized and sustained activities outside of mainstream institutions to challenge or defend existing power structures, policies, and norms
• Social movements can be local, national, or global in scope and vary in size, duration, and level of organization

Types of social movements

Top images from around the web for Types of social movements

• 

  Women’s Movements | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Types and Stages of Social Movements | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social Movements · Sociology 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Women’s Movements | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Types and Stages of Social Movements | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Types of social movements

• 

  Women’s Movements | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Types and Stages of Social Movements | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Social Movements · Sociology 2e View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Women’s Movements | HIST 1302: US after 1877 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Types and Stages of Social Movements | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Reform movements seek to modify specific policies or practices within the existing system (women's suffrage movement)
• Revolutionary movements aim to fundamentally transform the entire social, economic, or political order (Russian Revolution)
• Reactionary movements try to reverse recent changes and restore a previous status quo (White supremacist movements)
• Self-help movements focus on improving the lives of movement participants rather than broader societal change (Alcoholics Anonymous)

Goals of social movements

• Raise awareness about social problems or injustices and shift public opinion
• Pressure decision-makers to change laws, policies, or practices
• Empower marginalized communities and amplify their voices
• Defend the rights and interests of particular groups
• Transform cultural norms, values, and identities

Strategies of social movements

• Social movements employ a variety of strategies and tactics to achieve their goals, which can be categorized as nonviolent or violent
• The choice of strategies depends on factors such as the movement's ideology, resources, opponents, and political context
• Movements often use a combination of strategies and adapt their tactics over time in response to changing circumstances

Nonviolent resistance tactics

• Protests, marches, and rallies to demonstrate public support and generate media attention (March on Washington)
• Boycotts and strikes to disrupt economic activities and pressure targets to meet demands (Montgomery Bus Boycott)
• Civil disobedience, such as sit-ins, occupations, and blockades, to directly challenge unjust laws or policies (Occupy Wall Street)
• Petitions, letter-writing campaigns, and lawsuits to advocate for change through official channels (NAACP legal challenges to segregation)

Violent resistance tactics

• Property destruction, such as vandalism and arson, to disrupt the status quo and draw attention to grievances (British suffragettes)
• Physical confrontations with opponents, such as riots and street fighting, to defend movement interests or retaliate against repression (Stonewall Riots)
• Assassinations, bombings, and armed struggle to overthrow the existing order or coerce concessions (IRA campaign during the Troubles)
• Violent tactics are more controversial and can alienate potential supporters, provoke harsher repression, and undermine a movement's legitimacy

Lobbying and political influence

• Movements seek to shape policy outcomes by lobbying elected officials, government agencies, and other decision-makers
• Tactics include meeting with politicians, testifying at hearings, drafting legislation, and mobilizing constituents to pressure representatives
• Movements may form alliances with political parties, endorse candidates, or run their own candidates in elections
• Some movements establish professional advocacy organizations and think tanks to influence policy debates and public opinion (National Rifle Association)

Impact on public opinion

• Social movements can significantly shape public attitudes, beliefs, and discourse on the issues they address
• Successful movements often follow a "hearts and minds" strategy to win sympathy and support from the broader public
• Movements use various communication strategies, such as framing, narratives, and symbols, to shape how their issues are perceived and discussed

Shifting attitudes and beliefs

• Movements challenge prevailing assumptions and stereotypes about marginalized groups or social problems
• They offer new perspectives, information, and moral arguments to persuade the public to reconsider their views
• Over time, movements can contribute to long-term opinion trends, such as increasing support for same-sex marriage or environmental protection

Media coverage and framing

• Movements rely on media coverage to reach a wider audience and influence public opinion
• They stage events, create compelling visuals, and craft resonant messages to attract media attention
• However, media may ignore, trivialize, or negatively portray movements, especially if they challenge powerful interests or dominant norms
• Movements also create their own media, such as websites, social media, and documentaries, to control their narrative and bypass gatekeepers

Celebrity involvement and endorsement

• Celebrities can bring visibility, credibility, and resources to a movement by publicly supporting its goals and participating in its activities
• They can attract media coverage, mobilize fans, and influence public opinion through their platform and status
• However, celebrity involvement can also overshadow grassroots voices, depoliticize issues, or co-opt movements for personal gain
• Examples include Jane Fonda's anti-Vietnam War activism, Bono's ONE Campaign, and #MeToo's Hollywood supporters

Legislative and policy changes

• One of the main goals of social movements is to bring about changes in laws, policies, and practices that affect their constituencies
• Movements pressure policymakers and institutions through various tactics, such as lobbying, litigation, and electoral politics
• The success of policy advocacy depends on factors such as public opinion, political opportunities, movement resources, and counter-movement opposition

Successful policy outcomes

• Some movements have achieved significant legislative and policy victories that addressed their grievances and demands
• Examples include the civil rights movement's landmark laws (Civil Rights Act, Voting Rights Act), the environmental movement's regulations (Clean Air Act, Endangered Species Act), and the labor movement's protections (minimum wage, overtime pay)
• Policy successes can provide tangible benefits to movement constituencies, create new rights and entitlements, and establish movement goals as societal norms

Unsuccessful policy attempts

• Many movements face setbacks, delays, and defeats in their policy advocacy efforts due to various obstacles and constraints
• Policymakers may resist movement demands due to ideological opposition, conflicting interests, or institutional barriers
• Movements may lack sufficient resources, allies, or public support to overcome opposition and enact their preferred policies
• Examples include the failure to pass the Equal Rights Amendment, the defeat of comprehensive immigration reform, and the rollback of voting rights protections

Factors influencing policy success

• Political opportunities, such as shifts in public opinion, changes in government, or crises that create policy windows
• Movement resources, such as funding, expertise, and partnerships with influential allies and organizations
• Framing and messaging that resonates with policymakers and the public and counters opposition narratives
• Electoral and institutional strategies, such as voter mobilization, candidate endorsements, and litigation
• Opposition from counter-movements, business interests, and other powerful actors that seek to maintain the status quo or advance alternative policies

Cultural and societal shifts

• Beyond policy changes, social movements can have far-reaching effects on cultural norms, values, and practices
• They challenge dominant ideologies and offer alternative visions of social relations, identities, and ways of life
• Movements contribute to long-term cultural shifts by influencing public discourse, media representations, and everyday interactions

Changes in social norms

• Movements can destigmatize and normalize previously marginalized or taboo identities, behaviors, and issues
• They promote new norms of inclusion, equality, and respect for diversity
• Examples include the LGBTQ+ movement's impact on attitudes toward sexual orientation and gender identity, the feminist movement's challenge to patriarchal norms, and the disability rights movement's advocacy for accessibility and inclusion

Increased awareness and dialogue

• Movements raise public consciousness about social problems and injustices that were previously ignored or suppressed
• They create spaces for marginalized voices to be heard and for people to share their experiences and perspectives
• Movements foster dialogue and debate about issues of power, privilege, and oppression in various settings, such as schools, workplaces, and communities
• Examples include the Black Lives Matter movement's spotlight on systemic racism and police brutality, the #MeToo movement's exposure of sexual harassment and assault, and the climate justice movement's emphasis on the disproportionate impacts of climate change on vulnerable communities

Backlash and counter-movements

• As movements challenge dominant norms and power structures, they often face backlash and resistance from those who benefit from the status quo
• Counter-movements emerge to defend traditional values, identities, and interests against movement demands
• Backlash can take various forms, such as negative media coverage, harassment and violence against activists, and policy rollbacks
• Examples include the rise of the religious right in response to the women's and LGBTQ+ movements, the white supremacist movement's opposition to racial justice activism, and the fossil fuel industry's campaigns against climate action

Long-term effects on institutions

• Over time, social movements can lead to significant changes in the policies, practices, and cultures of major institutions, such as education, business, and government
• As movement ideas and values gain wider acceptance, they become institutionalized and shape the norms and expectations of these sectors
• Institutional changes can outlast the original movements and have enduring impacts on society

Educational curriculum changes

• Movements have fought to include the histories, perspectives, and contributions of marginalized groups in school curricula
• They have challenged biased and exclusionary content and advocated for more diverse and inclusive educational materials and practices
• Examples include the integration of African American studies, women's studies, and ethnic studies programs in higher education, the inclusion of LGBTQ+ history and issues in K-12 education, and the push for more accurate and critical teaching about racism, colonialism, and social injustice

Corporate policies and practices

• Movements have pressured corporations to adopt more socially and environmentally responsible policies and practices
• They have used tactics such as boycotts, shareholder activism, and public campaigns to hold companies accountable for their impacts on workers, communities, and the environment
• Examples include the anti-sweatshop movement's influence on labor standards in the garment industry, the divestment movement's impact on corporate policies on apartheid, fossil fuels, and other issues, and the fair trade movement's promotion of more ethical and sustainable business practices

Government agency reforms

• Movements have advocated for changes in the policies, procedures, and cultures of government agencies to make them more responsive, accountable, and equitable
• They have pushed for greater transparency, oversight, and community input in decision-making processes
• Examples include the environmental justice movement's influence on the Environmental Protection Agency's policies on pollution and health disparities, the prison reform movement's impact on the Department of Justice's policies on sentencing and conditions of confinement, and the immigrant rights movement's advocacy for changes in Immigration and Customs Enforcement's enforcement practices

Interaction with other movements

• Social movements do not exist in isolation but often interact with other movements that share similar goals, constituencies, or strategies
• These interactions can take various forms, such as collaboration, competition, or conflict, and can shape the trajectories and outcomes of the movements involved

Intersectionality and collaboration

• Many movements recognize the intersections of different forms of oppression and the need for solidarity and collaboration across issues and identities
• They form coalitions and alliances to pool resources, coordinate actions, and amplify their impact
• Examples include the reproductive justice movement's integration of racial, economic, and gender justice issues, the Movement for Black Lives' coalition of various racial justice organizations, and the climate justice movement's partnerships with labor, indigenous, and community groups

Competition for resources and attention

• Movements often compete with each other for limited resources, such as funding, media attention, and public support
• This competition can lead to tensions and conflicts between movements that have different priorities, strategies, or constituencies
• Examples include the historical tensions between the mainstream environmental movement and the environmental justice movement over issues of race and class, the debates within the women's movement over the prioritization of different issues and tactics, and the competition between various identity-based movements for foundation grants and donor support

Ideological conflicts and divisions

• Movements can also have ideological differences and disagreements that lead to internal divisions and external conflicts
• These conflicts can be based on different political philosophies, strategic approaches, or visions of social change
• Examples include the splits within the civil rights movement between advocates of nonviolence and self-defense, the tensions within the LGBTQ+ movement between assimilationist and liberationist perspectives, and the debates within the labor movement between those who prioritize organizing workers and those who focus on electoral politics and policy advocacy

Challenges faced by movements

• Social movements face numerous challenges and obstacles in their efforts to bring about social change
• These challenges can come from both internal factors, such as organizational and strategic issues, and external factors, such as opposition and repression

Sustaining momentum and engagement

• Movements often struggle to maintain the energy, enthusiasm, and commitment of participants over time, especially in the face of setbacks and slow progress
• They need to find ways to keep people motivated, engaged, and active in the face of burnout, disillusionment, and competing demands on their time and resources
• Examples include the challenge of sustaining the Occupy Wall Street movement beyond its initial encampments, the difficulty of maintaining the intensity of the Women's March protests after the first year, and the need for the Black Lives Matter movement to keep people mobilized and engaged in the long-term struggle for racial justice

Internal disagreements and factions

• Movements are not monolithic but often contain diverse individuals and groups with different backgrounds, perspectives, and interests
• These differences can lead to internal disagreements, factions, and power struggles that can undermine the movement's unity and effectiveness
• Examples include the tensions between younger and older activists in the civil rights movement, the conflicts between radical and moderate factions in the women's movement, and the debates between different ideological and strategic tendencies in the socialist movement

External opposition and resistance

• Movements often face strong opposition and resistance from powerful actors and institutions that seek to maintain the status quo or defend their interests
• This opposition can take various forms, such as counter-movements, media attacks, legal challenges, and state repression
• Examples include the violent repression of the labor movement by corporations and the government in the early 20th century, the FBI's surveillance and infiltration of the civil rights and anti-war movements in the 1960s, and the backlash against the LGBTQ+ movement by religious conservatives and right-wing politicians

Evaluating movement effectiveness

• Assessing the impact and effectiveness of social movements is a complex and contested process that involves different criteria, perspectives, and time horizons
• Movements can have various intended and unintended consequences, and their legacies can be interpreted and evaluated differently by different actors and audiences

Measuring short-term vs long-term impact

• Movements can have immediate, visible impacts, such as policy changes, media attention, or public opinion shifts, but these may not necessarily translate into long-term, systemic changes
• Conversely, movements may not achieve their short-term goals but still contribute to long-term cultural, political, and institutional changes that are harder to measure and attribute
• Examples include the civil rights movement's achievement of landmark legislation in the 1960s but the persistence of racial inequalities and injustices decades later, the women's movement's failure to pass the Equal Rights Amendment but its long-term impact on gender norms and expectations, and the anti-globalization movement's lack of immediate policy successes but its influence on the discourse and politics of global economic governance

Intended vs unintended consequences

• Movements' actions and strategies can have unintended consequences that may undermine or contradict their goals and values
• These consequences can include backlash and repression, co-optation and compromise, or the reproduction of oppressive dynamics within the movement itself
• Examples include the way that some environmental movements' focus on individual behavior change can depoliticize and distract from systemic issues, the way that some feminist movements' emphasis on women's empowerment can reinforce neoliberal and individualistic values, and the way that some anti-racist movements' use of social media can lead to performative activism and in-fighting

Debates over movement legacy

• The legacy and significance of social movements are often contested and reinterpreted by different actors and audiences over time
• Movements may be celebrated and mythologized by some as heroic struggles for justice and freedom, while criticized and delegitimized by others as divisive and destructive forces
• The memory and meaning of movements can be shaped by various factors, such as political agendas, cultural representations, and historical revisionism
• Examples include the debates over the legacy of the Black Power movement and its relationship to the civil rights movement, the controversies over the commemoration and memorialization of the Stonewall Riots and the LGBTQ+ movement, and the disputes over the interpretation and significance of the Arab Spring uprisings and their aftermath