7.1 Poverty and income inequality

Poverty and income inequality are critical issues in understanding social change and racial and gender disparities. These concepts highlight the uneven distribution of resources and opportunities in society, affecting individuals' ability to meet basic needs and participate fully in economic life.

Measuring poverty involves complex methods, from absolute thresholds to relative comparisons. Causes range from individual factors like education to structural issues like systemic racism. Consequences of poverty impact health, education, and social inclusion, perpetuating cycles of disadvantage across generations.

Defining poverty and income inequality

• Poverty refers to a state of lacking sufficient financial resources to meet basic needs such as food, shelter, and healthcare
• Income inequality describes the uneven distribution of income and wealth across a population, with a small percentage holding a disproportionate share of resources
• Understanding poverty and inequality is crucial for addressing issues of social justice, economic mobility, and overall societal well-being in the context of social change and racial and gender disparities

Measuring poverty

Absolute vs relative poverty

Top images from around the web for Absolute vs relative poverty

• 

  Relative Poverty Measures Can Help Paint a More Accurate picture of Poverty in 21st Century ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Income Inequality: How Do Racial and Gender Differences Influence the Incomes in US View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Global trends in relative and absolute income inequality View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Relative Poverty Measures Can Help Paint a More Accurate picture of Poverty in 21st Century ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Income Inequality: How Do Racial and Gender Differences Influence the Incomes in US View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Absolute vs relative poverty

• 

  Relative Poverty Measures Can Help Paint a More Accurate picture of Poverty in 21st Century ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Income Inequality: How Do Racial and Gender Differences Influence the Incomes in US View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Global trends in relative and absolute income inequality View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Relative Poverty Measures Can Help Paint a More Accurate picture of Poverty in 21st Century ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Income Inequality: How Do Racial and Gender Differences Influence the Incomes in US View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Absolute poverty defines a fixed threshold based on the cost of essential goods and services, regardless of the overall standard of living in a society
• Relative poverty considers an individual's resources in relation to the average or median income within a specific population
• Relative poverty lines often set at 50% or 60% of median income, capturing the notion of social exclusion and inability to participate fully in society

Official poverty measures

• U.S. Census Bureau's official poverty measure, developed in the 1960s, calculates poverty thresholds based on the cost of a minimum food diet, adjusted for household size
• Compares pre-tax cash income to poverty thresholds, which vary by family size and composition but do not account for geographic differences in cost of living
• Criticized for outdated assumptions and failure to include non-cash benefits (SNAP) or tax credits (EITC)

Supplemental poverty measure

• Developed in 2011 to address limitations of the official poverty measure and provide a more comprehensive assessment of economic well-being
• Accounts for a broader range of necessary expenses (housing, clothing, utilities) and adjusts thresholds based on geographic differences in housing costs
• Includes the impact of government benefits and taxes on household resources, offering a more accurate picture of the effects of anti-poverty policies

International poverty lines

• World Bank's international poverty lines allow for global comparisons of poverty rates and progress in poverty reduction across countries
• Current international poverty line set at $1.90 per day, based on the average national poverty lines of the poorest countries, adjusted for purchasing power parity (PPP)
• Higher poverty lines ($3.20 and$5.50 per day) capture the reality of poverty in middle-income countries with higher costs of living

Causes of poverty

Individual factors

• Low levels of education and skills limit access to well-paying jobs and hinder upward economic mobility
• Health issues, disabilities, or substance abuse problems can impede an individual's ability to work and earn a stable income
• Single parenthood, particularly among women, increases the risk of poverty due to the challenges of balancing work and childcare responsibilities on a single income

Structural factors

• Systemic racism and discrimination in education, employment, housing, and the criminal justice system perpetuate economic disadvantages for marginalized groups
• Deindustrialization and the decline of unions have led to a loss of stable, well-paying jobs, particularly in manufacturing sectors
• Globalization and technological advancements have contributed to job displacement and wage stagnation for lower-skilled workers

Cyclical nature of poverty

• Poverty tends to be intergenerational, with children born into poor families facing greater obstacles to escaping poverty in adulthood
• Limited access to quality education, healthcare, and social networks in impoverished communities reinforces the cycle of poverty across generations
• Concentrated poverty in certain neighborhoods or regions can create self-reinforcing dynamics, such as reduced economic opportunities and higher crime rates

Consequences of poverty

Health and well-being

• Poverty is associated with higher rates of chronic illnesses, mental health problems, and reduced life expectancy due to limited access to preventive care and healthy living conditions
• Food insecurity and malnutrition are more prevalent among low-income households, affecting physical and cognitive development, particularly in children
• Exposure to environmental hazards (lead, air pollution) is more common in impoverished communities, leading to adverse health outcomes

Educational attainment

• Children from low-income families are more likely to attend underfunded schools with fewer resources and less experienced teachers, hindering academic achievement
• Financial constraints and the need to work can limit access to higher education, reducing future earning potential and perpetuating the cycle of poverty
• Chronic stress associated with poverty can impact cognitive development and academic performance, further widening educational disparities

Crime and incarceration

• Poverty and lack of economic opportunities are correlated with higher crime rates, as individuals may turn to illegal activities to meet basic needs or gain financial resources
• Over-policing and harsher sentencing practices in low-income communities contribute to disproportionate incarceration rates among the poor, particularly for racial and ethnic minorities
• Incarceration can further entrench poverty by creating barriers to employment, housing, and social services upon release

Social exclusion and stigma

• Poverty can lead to social isolation and exclusion from mainstream society, as individuals may lack the resources to participate in social activities or maintain social networks
• Stigmatization and negative stereotypes associated with poverty can result in discrimination and reduced access to opportunities, such as employment or housing
• Internalized shame and reduced self-esteem among those living in poverty can further hinder their ability to advocate for themselves and seek assistance

Income inequality

Measuring income inequality

• Gini coefficient is a common measure of income inequality, ranging from 0 (perfect equality) to 1 (perfect inequality), based on the distribution of income across a population
• Income quintiles or deciles compare the share of total income held by each fifth or tenth of the population, ranked from lowest to highest income
• Top income shares (top 1% or 0.1%) capture the concentration of income among the highest earners and the growing disconnect between their economic gains and the rest of the population

Trends in income inequality

• Income inequality has been rising in many developed countries, particularly the United States, since the 1970s, with a widening gap between the rich and the poor
• Wages for lower and middle-income workers have stagnated, while high-income earners have seen substantial gains, leading to a shrinking middle class
• Wealth inequality is even more pronounced than income inequality, as the top percentiles hold a disproportionate share of assets (stocks, real estate) that appreciate over time

Causes of rising inequality

• Globalization has led to increased competition for low-skilled jobs and the offshoring of manufacturing, putting downward pressure on wages for less-educated workers
• Technological advancements have automated many routine tasks, reducing demand for certain types of labor and contributing to job polarization
• Decline of unions and erosion of collective bargaining power has weakened the ability of workers to negotiate for higher wages and better benefits
• Tax policies favoring the wealthy (reduced top marginal tax rates, preferential treatment of capital gains) have exacerbated the concentration of income and wealth

Poverty and inequality by race and gender

Racial disparities in poverty rates

• In the U.S., poverty rates are significantly higher among racial and ethnic minorities, with African Americans and Hispanics experiencing poverty at more than twice the rate of non-Hispanic whites
• Structural racism, including historical legacies of slavery, segregation, and discrimination, has created persistent barriers to economic mobility for communities of color
• Racial wealth gap is even larger than the income gap, as minorities have been systematically excluded from opportunities for homeownership and intergenerational wealth transfer

Gender and the feminization of poverty

• Women are more likely to experience poverty than men, with single mothers and elderly women being particularly vulnerable
• Gender wage gap, with women earning less than men for comparable work, contributes to women's higher poverty rates
• Disproportionate responsibility for unpaid caregiving work falls on women, limiting their ability to participate fully in the labor market and achieve economic independence

Intersectionality of race, gender, and poverty

• Intersectionality recognizes that multiple marginalized identities (race, gender, class) interact to shape unique experiences of oppression and disadvantage
• Women of color face compounded economic challenges due to the intersection of racial and gender discrimination in education, employment, and other domains
• Poverty rates are highest among single mothers of color, who navigate the combined effects of racial, gender, and class-based inequities

Theories explaining poverty and inequality

Culture of poverty theory

• Developed by anthropologist Oscar Lewis, suggests that poverty is perpetuated through a distinct set of values, attitudes, and behaviors passed down across generations
• Argues that the poor develop coping mechanisms and adaptations to survive in conditions of scarcity, which can hinder their ability to escape poverty
• Criticized for blaming the poor for their circumstances and overlooking structural factors that create and maintain poverty

Structural functionalism

• Views poverty and inequality as inevitable and even necessary for the functioning of society, as they provide incentives for individuals to work hard and strive for success
• Suggests that the poor serve important functions, such as filling low-wage jobs essential for the economy and providing a reserve labor force
• Criticized for justifying and normalizing poverty and inequality, and for failing to address the systemic barriers that limit economic mobility

Conflict theory

• Rooted in Marxist thought, emphasizes the role of power imbalances and exploitation in creating and maintaining poverty and inequality
• Argues that the wealthy and powerful use their influence to shape social, economic, and political institutions in ways that protect their interests and perpetuate their advantages
• Highlights how capitalism and the concentration of wealth in the hands of a few inherently create poverty and inequality as a byproduct of the system

Policies addressing poverty and inequality

Welfare programs and social safety nets

• Means-tested programs (TANF, SNAP, Medicaid) provide cash assistance, food aid, and healthcare coverage to low-income individuals and families
• Social insurance programs (Social Security, Unemployment Insurance) offer protection against loss of income due to retirement, disability, or job loss
• Critics argue that welfare programs can create dependency and disincentives to work, while proponents emphasize their role in alleviating poverty and promoting stability

Progressive taxation and redistribution

• Progressive tax systems, where higher earners pay a larger share of their income in taxes, can reduce income inequality by redistributing wealth
• Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) provides refundable tax credits to low-income working families, effectively boosting their incomes and encouraging work
• Estate taxes and wealth taxes can help reduce the concentration of wealth across generations and fund anti-poverty initiatives

Education and job training initiatives

• Investing in early childhood education, particularly for disadvantaged children, can improve long-term educational and economic outcomes
• Increasing access to affordable, high-quality higher education and vocational training can help individuals acquire the skills needed for well-paying jobs
• Targeted job training programs can help workers adapt to changing labor market demands and reduce skills mismatches that contribute to unemployment and underemployment

Affirmative action and anti-discrimination laws

• Affirmative action policies aim to increase diversity and representation of marginalized groups in education and employment, helping to level the playing field
• Anti-discrimination laws (Civil Rights Act, Equal Pay Act) prohibit discrimination based on race, gender, and other protected characteristics in various domains
• Enforcement of these laws and proactive efforts to promote inclusion can help reduce structural barriers and improve economic opportunities for disadvantaged groups

Global poverty and inequality

Poverty in developing nations

• Extreme poverty, defined as living on less than $1.90 per day, is concentrated in developing countries, particularly in Sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia
• Factors contributing to poverty in developing nations include lack of infrastructure, limited access to education and healthcare, political instability, and vulnerability to natural disasters
• Poverty in developing countries often intersects with other challenges, such as food insecurity, child mortality, and gender inequality

International aid and development

• Official Development Assistance (ODA) from wealthy nations and multilateral institutions aims to support economic development and poverty reduction in developing countries
• Aid can take the form of grants, loans, technical assistance, and debt relief, and is often tied to specific projects or sectors (healthcare, education, infrastructure)
• Debates surrounding aid effectiveness and dependency have led to calls for more targeted, results-oriented approaches and greater emphasis on local ownership and capacity building

Globalization and its impact

• Globalization has led to increased trade, foreign investment, and economic integration across countries, with mixed effects on poverty and inequality
• While some developing countries have benefited from access to global markets and job creation in export-oriented industries, others have faced challenges such as job displacement and reduced policy autonomy
• Critics argue that globalization has primarily benefited multinational corporations and wealthy nations, while exacerbating inequality and undermining labor and environmental standards in developing countries

Debates and controversies

Personal responsibility vs structural barriers

• The debate over personal responsibility versus structural barriers centers on the extent to which individual choices and behaviors contribute to poverty, as opposed to systemic factors beyond individual control
• Proponents of personal responsibility emphasize the role of hard work, education, and decision-making in determining economic outcomes, and may view poverty as a result of individual failings
• Those emphasizing structural barriers point to the ways in which social, economic, and political systems create and perpetuate inequalities, limiting opportunities for certain groups regardless of individual efforts

Welfare reform and its consequences

• Welfare reform in the U.S., particularly the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (PRWORA) of 1996, aimed to reduce welfare dependency and encourage work
• Key changes included time limits on cash assistance, work requirements for recipients, and increased state flexibility in administering welfare programs
• Proponents argue that reform successfully reduced welfare rolls and increased employment, while critics contend that it led to increased poverty and hardship for many families, particularly during economic downturns

Universal basic income proposals

• Universal Basic Income (UBI) proposals call for providing all citizens with a regular, unconditional cash payment to cover basic needs, regardless of work status or income level
• Proponents argue that UBI could reduce poverty, provide a safety net in the face of job automation, and promote greater freedom and creativity by decoupling work from survival
• Critics raise concerns about the cost of implementing UBI, potential disincentives to work, and the political feasibility of such a significant policy change
• Experiments with UBI and similar cash transfer programs have yielded mixed results, with ongoing debates about their effectiveness and scalability as a solution to poverty and inequality