7.7 Islamic philosophy

Islamic philosophy emerged as a synthesis of Greek, Persian, and Islamic traditions, shaping intellectual discourse in the medieval Islamic world. This philosophical tradition played a crucial role in preserving and expanding upon classical knowledge, influencing the development of World Literature.

Major schools of thought like Mu'tazila, Ash'arism, and the Peripatetic school developed diverse perspectives on metaphysics, ethics, and epistemology. These traditions significantly influenced literary works and intellectual discourse throughout the Islamic world, contributing to the rich tapestry of global philosophical thought.

Origins of Islamic philosophy

• Islamic philosophy emerged as a synthesis of Greek, Persian, and Islamic traditions, shaping intellectual discourse in the medieval Islamic world
• This philosophical tradition played a crucial role in preserving and expanding upon classical knowledge, influencing the development of World Literature

Greek and Persian influences

Top images from around the web for Greek and Persian influences

• 

  Early Islamic philosophy - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Aristotle - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Islamic philosophy - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Early Islamic philosophy - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Aristotle - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Greek and Persian influences

• 

  Early Islamic philosophy - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Aristotle - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Islamic philosophy - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Early Islamic philosophy - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Aristotle - Wikipedia View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Aristotelian logic and metaphysics heavily influenced Islamic philosophical thought
• Neoplatonic concepts integrated into Islamic philosophy, particularly in mystical traditions
• Persian Zoroastrian ideas contributed to discussions on ethics and the nature of good and evil
• Translation movement in Baghdad (8th-9th centuries) made Greek philosophical texts accessible to Muslim scholars

Quranic foundations

• Quranic verses on nature, creation, and human existence inspired philosophical inquiry
• Concept of tawhid (divine unity) formed the basis for Islamic metaphysical discussions
• Quranic emphasis on knowledge and reason encouraged the pursuit of philosophy
• Ethical teachings in the Quran influenced Islamic moral philosophy

Early Islamic scholars

• Mu'tazilite theologians pioneered rational approaches to Islamic doctrine
• Al-Kindi (801-873 CE) known as the "Philosopher of the Arabs" introduced Greek philosophy to the Islamic world
• Ibn al-Rawandi (827-911 CE) challenged traditional religious interpretations with philosophical arguments
• Al-Razi (854-925 CE) advocated for the supremacy of reason over religious authority

Major schools of thought

• Islamic philosophy developed diverse schools of thought, each offering unique perspectives on metaphysics, ethics, and epistemology
• These philosophical traditions significantly influenced literary works and intellectual discourse throughout the Islamic world

Mu'tazila vs Ash'arism

• Mu'tazila emphasized reason and free will in interpreting Islamic doctrine
• Ash'arism developed as a response to Mu'tazila, advocating for a more traditional approach
• Debate centered on the nature of God's attributes and human responsibility
• Mu'tazila influenced by Greek rationalism, while Ash'arism sought to reconcile reason with revelation

Peripatetic school

• Founded on Aristotelian philosophy, adapted to Islamic context
• Al-Farabi and Avicenna were prominent figures in this tradition
• Focused on logic, physics, and metaphysics
• Developed theories on the nature of existence and the structure of the universe

Illuminationist philosophy

• Established by Shahab al-Din Suhrawardi in the 12th century
• Combined Neoplatonic ideas with Persian and Islamic mysticism
• Emphasized intuitive knowledge and spiritual illumination
• Influenced later Sufi philosophical traditions

Transcendent theosophy

• Developed by Mulla Sadra in the 17th century
• Synthesized various Islamic philosophical traditions
• Introduced the concept of substantial motion in metaphysics
• Explored the relationship between existence and essence

Key philosophical concepts

• Islamic philosophy grappled with fundamental questions about reality, knowledge, and ethics
• These concepts profoundly influenced literary works, particularly in poetry and mystical writings

Existence vs essence

• Debate over which precedes the other: existence (wujud) or essence (mahiyya)
• Avicenna argued for the primacy of essence, while later philosophers like Mulla Sadra prioritized existence
• Concept of "necessary existence" (wajib al-wujud) applied to God as the ultimate reality
• Distinction between contingent beings and the necessary being (God)

Causality in Islamic thought

• Explored the nature of cause and effect in the universe
• Al-Ghazali's critique of Aristotelian causality in "The Incoherence of the Philosophers"
• Averroes' defense of causality in "The Incoherence of the Incoherence"
• Occasionalism: theory that God directly causes all events, rejecting secondary causes

Divine attributes

• Debate over how to understand God's attributes mentioned in the Quran
• Mu'tazila argued for a metaphorical interpretation to preserve divine unity
• Ash'arites developed the concept of bi-la kayf ("without asking how") to affirm attributes without anthropomorphism
• Philosophical discussions on the relationship between divine essence and attributes

Free will vs predestination

• Central debate in Islamic theology and philosophy
• Mu'tazila advocated for human free will and moral responsibility
• Ash'arites developed the concept of "acquisition" (kasb) to reconcile divine decree with human agency
• Philosophical explorations of divine foreknowledge and its implications for human freedom

Prominent Islamic philosophers

• These thinkers made significant contributions to Islamic philosophy and world literature
• Their works influenced both Islamic and Western intellectual traditions for centuries

Al-Kindi's contributions

• Introduced Greek philosophy to the Islamic world
• Emphasized the compatibility of philosophy with Islamic revelation
• Developed a theory of intellect influenced by Aristotle and Neoplatonism
• Wrote on a wide range of subjects including mathematics, astronomy, and medicine

Al-Farabi's political philosophy

• Known as the "Second Teacher" after Aristotle
• Developed the concept of the "virtuous city" (al-madina al-fadila)
• Explored the relationship between religion and philosophy in political governance
• Influenced by Plato's "Republic" but adapted to Islamic context

Avicenna's metaphysics

• Wrote "The Book of Healing," a comprehensive philosophical encyclopedia
• Developed the influential "flying man" thought experiment to prove the soul's existence
• Introduced the concept of the "necessary existent" to prove God's existence
• Explored the nature of universals and particulars in his logic and metaphysics

Averroes and Aristotelianism

• Known as "The Commentator" for his extensive commentaries on Aristotle
• Defended philosophy against Al-Ghazali's critiques in "The Incoherence of the Incoherence"
• Developed the theory of the unity of the intellect
• Influenced medieval Christian and Jewish philosophy, particularly in Europe

Islamic philosophy and literature

• Islamic philosophical ideas permeated various forms of literature, enriching the cultural and intellectual landscape
• This intersection of philosophy and literature contributed significantly to the development of World Literature

Philosophical poetry

• Persian poet Omar Khayyam incorporated philosophical themes into his Rubaiyat
• Ibn Sina (Avicenna) composed philosophical poems to explain complex concepts
• Sufi poets like Rumi and Ibn Arabi wove philosophical ideas into their mystical verses
• Philosophical allegories presented in poetic form (Hayy ibn Yaqdhan by Ibn Tufail)

Allegorical narratives

• Ibn Tufail's "Hayy ibn Yaqdhan" explored philosophical concepts through a Robinson Crusoe-like tale
• Suhrawardi's "The Red Intellect" used symbolic narratives to convey illuminationist philosophy
• "The Conference of the Birds" by Attar presented Sufi philosophy through an allegorical journey
• These narratives influenced later Western literature, including Daniel Defoe's works

Sufi mystical writings

• Ibn Arabi's "Fusus al-Hikam" (The Bezels of Wisdom) explored complex metaphysical ideas
• Al-Ghazali's "The Alchemy of Happiness" combined philosophy with spiritual guidance
• Rumi's "Masnavi" incorporated Neoplatonic and Islamic philosophical concepts
• Sufi literature often used paradoxical language to express ineffable mystical experiences

Influence on Western thought

• Islamic philosophy played a crucial role in the transmission and development of philosophical ideas in the West
• This cross-cultural exchange significantly impacted the course of World Literature and intellectual history

Transmission to medieval Europe

• Islamic philosophical texts translated into Latin during the 12th-13th centuries
• Toledo School of Translators in Spain facilitated the transfer of knowledge
• Works of Avicenna, Averroes, and Al-Farabi became available to European scholars
• Islamic commentaries on Aristotle influenced the revival of Aristotelianism in Europe

Impact on Scholasticism

• Thomas Aquinas engaged with Averroes' ideas in his philosophical works
• Avicenna's metaphysics influenced the development of medieval Christian philosophy
• Debates on faith and reason in Islamic philosophy echoed in Scholastic discussions
• Concept of the "active intellect" from Islamic philosophy adopted by some Christian thinkers

Islamic philosophy in Renaissance

• Averroes' commentaries on Aristotle studied in Italian universities
• Neoplatonic elements in Islamic philosophy influenced Renaissance Platonism
• Islamic philosophical works contributed to the revival of classical learning
• Debates on the eternity of the world from Islamic philosophy resurfaced in Renaissance thought

Contemporary Islamic philosophy

• Modern Islamic philosophy continues to engage with classical traditions while addressing contemporary issues
• This ongoing philosophical discourse contributes to the evolving landscape of World Literature

Modernist interpretations

• Muhammad Abduh (1849-1905) sought to reconcile Islamic thought with modern science
• Muhammad Iqbal (1877-1938) developed a philosophy of selfhood and creativity
• Fazlur Rahman (1919-1988) proposed a contextual approach to interpreting Islamic texts
• Contemporary thinkers explore Islamic responses to postmodernism and globalization

Traditionalist approaches

• Seyyed Hossein Nasr advocates for the preservation of traditional Islamic philosophy
• Traditionalists emphasize the perennial wisdom in classical Islamic thought
• Critique of modernist interpretations as overly influenced by Western philosophy
• Efforts to revive and reinterpret classical Islamic philosophical concepts

Islamic philosophy in academia

• Increased interest in Islamic philosophy in Western universities
• Comparative studies between Islamic and Western philosophical traditions
• Development of new approaches to studying Islamic intellectual history
• Debates on the relevance of classical Islamic philosophy to contemporary issues

Challenges and controversies

• Islamic philosophy continues to grapple with tensions between tradition and innovation
• These debates reflect broader discussions in World Literature about cultural identity and intellectual exchange

Reconciling faith and reason

• Ongoing debates on the relationship between revelation and rational inquiry
• Efforts to develop Islamic epistemology that integrates both faith and reason
• Discussions on the limits of human reason in understanding divine truths
• Contemporary attempts to address scientific discoveries within Islamic philosophical frameworks

Critiques of Islamic philosophy

• Some conservative religious scholars view philosophy as a foreign influence in Islam
• Debates on the orthodoxy of certain philosophical positions (eternal universe)
• Critiques of Neoplatonic influences in Islamic mystical philosophy
• Discussions on the relevance of classical philosophical debates to modern Muslim societies

Debates on innovation vs tradition

• Tensions between preserving classical Islamic philosophy and developing new approaches
• Debates on the role of ijtihad (independent reasoning) in contemporary Islamic thought
• Discussions on adapting Islamic philosophy to address modern ethical issues (bioethics)
• Controversies surrounding attempts to "Islamize" modern philosophical concepts