3.5 Modes of Cultural Analysis

Evolutionary theories in anthropology explore how cultures develop over time. From unilineal models to complex ecological approaches, these theories attempt to explain cultural diversity. However, they face criticism for oversimplification and ethnocentrism, highlighting the need for nuanced understanding.

Functionalist perspectives view culture as an integrated system serving specific purposes. This approach examines how cultural practices maintain social stability. Meanwhile, ontological anthropology delves into different cultural understandings of reality, challenging Western assumptions about the nature of existence.

Evolutionary Theories and Critiques

Evolutionary theories in cultural studies

Top images from around the web for Evolutionary theories in cultural studies

• 

  Dimensions of Culture – CaseWORK View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Evoked Culture and Evoked Nature: The Promise of Gene-Culture Co-Evolution Theory ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Palaeos : Socio-Cultural Evolution View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Dimensions of Culture – CaseWORK View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Evoked Culture and Evoked Nature: The Promise of Gene-Culture Co-Evolution Theory ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Evolutionary theories in cultural studies

• 

  Dimensions of Culture – CaseWORK View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Evoked Culture and Evoked Nature: The Promise of Gene-Culture Co-Evolution Theory ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Palaeos : Socio-Cultural Evolution View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Dimensions of Culture – CaseWORK View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Evoked Culture and Evoked Nature: The Promise of Gene-Culture Co-Evolution Theory ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Unilineal evolution assumes all societies progress through the same stages (savagery, barbarism, civilization) in a linear fashion proposed by anthropologists like Lewis Henry Morgan
• Multilineal evolution posits that societies evolve in different ways based on their unique environments and histories, focusing on specific cultural traits rather than entire societies as advocated by Julian Steward
• Cultural ecology examines the relationship between a society's culture and its environment, emphasizing how adaptation to the environment shapes cultural practices (subsistence strategies, social organization)
• Sociobiology applies evolutionary principles (natural selection, kin selection) to explain social behaviors, emphasizing the role of genes in shaping human behavior as proposed by Edward O. Wilson

Critiques of evolutionary anthropology

• Ethnocentrism in evolutionary theories often assumes Western societies are more advanced while non-Western societies are viewed as primitive or less developed
• Cultural relativism challenges this by emphasizing the need to understand and evaluate cultures within their own context, without imposing external value judgments
• Oversimplification in evolutionary theories may not account for the complexity and diversity of human cultures, assuming a uniform path of development for all societies (ignores historical particularities)
• Lack of empirical evidence makes it difficult to prove that societies progress through specific stages due to limited historical and archaeological data to support evolutionary claims
• Neglect of agency and individual choice in evolutionary theories may overlook the role of human decision-making in shaping cultures, overemphasizing environmental and biological determinism (ignores cultural creativity)

Functionalist and Ontological Perspectives

Cultural functionality perspectives

• Culture as an integrated system where each aspect serves a specific function in maintaining the overall system, with changes in one part affecting other parts (holistic approach)
• Manifest functions are intended and recognized consequences of cultural practices (religious rituals promoting social cohesion), while latent functions are unintended and unrecognized consequences (Merton's distinction)
• Dysfunction refers to cultural practices that have negative consequences for the system, potentially leading to social problems or instability (drug abuse, crime)

Functionalism vs structural functionalism

• Malinowski's functionalism focuses on how cultural practices meet the biological and psychological needs of individuals, using a fieldwork-based approach that emphasizes understanding the native's point of view (participant observation)
• Radcliffe-Brown's structural functionalism focuses on how cultural practices maintain the overall structure of society, emphasizing the study of social relations and institutions rather than individuals and viewing society as a system of interrelated parts that work together to maintain equilibrium (social structure)

Ontological anthropology and reality

• Ontology is the study of the nature of being, existence, and reality, examining how different cultures conceptualize and experience reality (worldviews, cosmologies)
• Perspectivism (Viveiros de Castro) posits that different cultures have different perspectives on what constitutes reality, with humans and non-humans (animals, plants, spirits) viewed as persons with agency (Amazonian societies)
• Animism is the belief that non-human entities (animals, plants, objects) possess a spiritual essence or soul, challenging Western dichotomies between nature and culture, human and non-human (Indigenous religions)
• Multinaturalism is the idea that there are multiple natures or realities, rather than a single, universal nature, with different cultures inhabiting different ontological worlds with their own unique properties (Amazonian perspectivism)

Anthropological Research Methods and Perspectives

• Ethnography is a research method that involves immersive fieldwork to study and describe a culture from the inside, often combining participant observation with interviews and other data collection techniques
• The emic perspective refers to the insider's view of a culture, focusing on how members of that culture understand and interpret their own experiences and beliefs
• The etic perspective represents the outsider's or researcher's analytical view of a culture, using comparative frameworks and scientific concepts to understand cultural phenomena
• Symbolic anthropology examines how symbols and meanings are used within a culture to create and maintain social reality, focusing on the interpretation of cultural practices and beliefs
• Interpretive anthropology, influenced by Clifford Geertz, emphasizes the importance of "thick description" in understanding culture as a system of shared meanings and symbols that can be read and interpreted like a text